Re:Xkcd Password Generator
by Gullanian on Thursday August 11, 2011 @10:19AM
(#2872948)
Once hackers realise people are using ~4 random words for a password the entropy will decrease hugely.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I think you've got it backwards: the entropy calculation here assumes that the attacker already knows the scheme. The 2^44 possible passwords are therefore a lower boundary for the entropy.
In practice the attacker must cast a wider net because he doesn't know exactly which word list you use, or if you are using a completely different password scheme. This increases the difficulty.