Re:Google Admits Handing over European User Data to US Intel...
by mattmanser on Thursday August 11, 2011 @10:04AM
(#2872859)
That doesn't make one jot of sense.
By complying with the request they immediately violated the safe harbor provision.
Re:Google Admits Handing over European User Data to US Intel...
by omh on Thursday August 11, 2011 @10:16AM
(#2872931)
They certainly violated the spirit, but may not have violated any actual rules. I could imagine that there's some exclusion in the safe harbor rules for "national security".
It's not clear whether the Data Protection laws were ever designed to guard against national governments. I imagine that those who wrote them were really thinking about avoiding disclosure to private individuals or other companies.
If Google have exported the data to a US jurisdiction under Safe Harbor, then a subsequent PATRIOT Act request wouldn't need to involve any EU-stored data or EU companies.
This seems like a much more general issue with exceptions like Safe Harbor, and something that people/companies should bear in mind. Promises like "equivalent" protection don't help with new local laws which can always trump anything.