News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by xrd on Friday October 01, 2021 @01:37PM (#28721357)
Disclaimer: I'm working on a project in this space. So take what I say with a grain of salt.

There are very few projects doing anything interesting with web3 outside of speculation or "grifter" quasi-MLMs (NFTs). Until that changes, web3 won't be interesting. But, we are on the cusp of that change. Soon, there will be interesting applications on web3, and they will change the web permanently.

Two things stand in the way::

- web3 requires specialized browser plugin or even worse, a special app. You cannot do web3 inside a web2 browser.

- transaction costs and throughput

web3 requires a browser plugin (meaning not on mobile) AND education on how to use it. Those are blockers for 99% of the people, so you only have 1% of the people who will use it, and in that small population, most of them are there to get rich quick or die trying.

And, transaction costs are high for the web3 (I'm equating web3 with Ethereum). It only makes sense to participate for people who are trying to get rich.

BUT: if transaction costs go down, and people can participate in web3 WITHOUT a browser plugin, then people will start building interesting projects OUTSIDE of speculation and MLMs.

That will be the moment really exciting things start to happen.

When will that be?

If you don't know what L2 is, here is why it is important: L2 is a way to scale transaction throughput outside of the mainnet Ethereum. There are many ways to do it, but generally they involve rollups, either optimistic or ZK-proofs.

What's a rollup? A rollup is a way to do lots of smaller transactions off the main Ethereum network, and then roll them all up into a single main Ethereum transaction. You amortize all the small transactions across one single mainnet transaction.

L2 products are still in their infancy, don't work great, and have poor UI. But, they are one of many solutions to solving the transaction cost and throughput problem.

If you are rolling your eyes at ZK-proofs and saying "Oh, those crypto guys, more snake oil!" You should know that Google is using ZK-proofs to guarantee the information they pull from Android devices and processed in ML is has a guarantee of anonymity when shared into Google. There is a lot of interesting research happening despite all the grifting in crypto, so don't miss the good stuff. If you are excited about hard math, crypto has some fun work.

So, L2 will solve the "transaction cost and throughput problem."

The only other barrier is browser plugins, IMHO. The exciting thing is that L2 solutions have their own API. When one of them finallly offers a great UX for interacting with their network, you can interact with it using web2 and not with MetaMask.

Then, everything will open up. It's going to be soon.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by twalla on Friday October 01, 2021 @02:51PM (#28722126)
My biggest issue with the entire crypto space is I have to wade through a veritable ocean of shilling, memes and straight up disinformation to find substantial comments like this one.
Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by xrd on Friday October 01, 2021 @02:55PM (#28722154)
That really makes me laugh. So true.

I am still trying to find my voice but I am writing about all this here:

https://basqui.at

Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by twalla on Friday October 01, 2021 @03:10PM (#28722291)
Just read through it, it's good! Do you have any other high signal to noise sources for info - I fall somewhere between a crypto skeptic and pragmatist so it's _hard_ to find information that doesn't strike me as breathless PR or people trying to pump whatever they're currently bagholding.
Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by xrd on Friday October 01, 2021 @03:37PM (#28722539)
Thanks, I appreciate that. I don't have great sources of information yet.

Did you see my post regarding the DeFiant podcast with Nate Chastain from OpenSea? He's the one who resigned after he was allegedly purchasing NFTs anonymously and then trying to resell them. My favorite part of the podcast is when he noted NFTs are exciting because the blockchain is a transparent ledger, which is exactly why he got caught. It's so funny.

Almost all the information out there should be filtered through: "why is this person talking about this, what's their incentive?" Cryptocurrency is, of course, all about financial incentives, so that's fitting. And, make no mistake, there is a good reason I'm in here talking too...

Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by mofeeta on Friday October 01, 2021 @05:02PM (#28723355)
I've started to dive into smart contract development, mainly to do contracting on the side. Do you think this is a viable path? How is the job market for dapp/block chain developers?

I've been closely following the recommendations by zoenolan, here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28333766

Are there other resources you'd recommend?

Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by xrd on Friday October 01, 2021 @05:11PM (#28723425)
That's a great list. The only thing I found recently that is interesting is this:

https://www.cairo-lang.org/ https://github.com/martriay/nile/

Yes, learn and play with solidity.

That wasn't on the list, but if you don't know about remix, go there first.

https://remix.ethereum.org/

Hardhat is great, but you can do everything inside a browser with remix, it is amazing.

This is a good starting point video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XyoFT4QkoL4

Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by cupofjoakim on Friday October 01, 2021 @01:48PM (#28721472)
I think the browser plugin is a gigantic step. We're talking a whole new generation of browsers with native support having to roll in for this to gain traction, and most consumer traffic is mobile nowadays so it's not enough to ship to a PC and be satisfied there.

If it were to gain mainstream attraction it seems like we're talking at least five more years unless the chromium and safari teams pick this up and make it a priority.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by xrd on Friday October 01, 2021 @02:04PM (#28721658)
I totally agree. Other than Brave, it will be years until web3 is seamlessly intergrated.

But, my point about L2 solutions is that with those you have a work around.

web3 requires that you use secp256k1 ellptic curves. Those are not available in any browser. So, you cannot sign transactions. You cannot participate in Ethereum from a browser.

But, what if the L2 network does not require that curve? What if it accepts WebCrypto signed L2 transactions? Then, you can participate in Ethereum through L2. You might give up a little in terms of absolute security (these still have much better security than anything else out there, by the way), but for certain applications that might be a tradeoff worth having.

If you can manage transactions in a vanilla browser using WebCrypto (or bundling your own crypto in JS with browserify or something -- that's what I did), and the API is over HTTP instead of into an Ethereum node, then you can participate in a vanilla browser.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by ck_one on Friday October 01, 2021 @04:35PM (#28723139)
Why can't browser natively sign transactions using secp256k1? And why is that not required for L2 transactions?
Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by xrd on Friday October 01, 2021 @05:16PM (#28723462)
Browsers don't have that cryptographic primitive available.

L2s can choose whatever encryption schemes they want. They could use rot13 if their customers would be willing to work on a L2 chain with that compromise. :)

A blockchain (if you already know this, sorry...) is just a ledger with transactions created using public/private keys. Ethereum (and Bitcoin) use secp256k1. But, each blockchain can choose their own and L2s have different ones for different reasons. Eventually the L2 needs to put something back on L1 and that transaction has to be using the crytpo the L1 uses. But, the L2 can store into the L1 the answer to a ZK-proof (with the answer as a link in a Merkle tree), and how you manage transactions (and that Merkle tree) inside the L2 is up to the L2 managers.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by Abrownn on Friday October 01, 2021 @01:50PM (#28721498)
You've set yourself apart from the 'grifters' in the Web3 space in your comment but didn't explain much more than that about current use-cases. Could you elaborate on what it is you're making that's so unique?

Edit: Thanks for the interfacing explanation btw, very clear and concise.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by xrd on Friday October 01, 2021 @02:09PM (#28721714)
I'm building a way to accept microtransactions on regular websites inside regular vanilla browser.

https://finneyfor.com/

You can see transactions delivered using this method when I started this four years ago.

https://etherscan.io/address/d2bb82d40c8bcf50d008e39ecb9e44d...

Those were $1 transactions at the time. Now that ETH is worth $200+!

Transaction costs are such that I'm refactoring it to use L2, but my solution works inside vanilla browsers without a browser plugin.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by jimkleiber on Friday October 01, 2021 @05:54PM (#28723795)
I really like this idea (microtransactions) and yet don't really like the usage of ETH for them. Maybe this is unrelated, I guess I just want to receive payments in a currency that is relatively stable, and it seems like ETH, with so many people trying to make money off it rising in value (and maybe its monetary policy), has quite a volatile value.

Do you think web3 will work with such volatile currencies? Will these currencies stabilize?

I guess right now I'm hesitant to receive payment in crypto for that fear.

Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by xrd on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:15PM (#28724798)
I worked at a large e-commerce company with a marketplace of several hundred million. That's what Ethereum has, a massive set of users, at least compared to other cryptocurrencies. There is no reason why web3 won't work with anything else, but onboarding users is really, really hard with even Ethereum, and that's a problem for any app.

Your point should have been my third point in my long rant above.

Yes, until the price stabilizes, it will be less exciting for a lot of people.

But, until we have utility applications, the ecosystem will just be full of grifters causing instability.

Seems like a catch 22. But, hopefully utility applications will start to appear and that will help stabilize things. .

And, at least the value is consistent in rising, not falling. :)

Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by jimkleiber on Sunday October 03, 2021 @12:57AM (#28734638)
As a relative outsider to crypto, mostly jumping in with the oh-I-should-have-invested-in-2010-when-my-boss-told-me-about-it, I wonder if some structural elements are causing the price instability, or rather, making them be less like currencies and more like gold.

Perhaps ETH is different in this, as I don't know it well. I know BTC is deflationary by default, and so it seems to be ripe for prospecting/grifting: "buy it today, it'll be worth more in the future! HODL!" If I have a currency that I think will almost certainly be worth more the next day, why would I spend it? Who wants to be the $80M pizza guy?

From what I can tell about ETH, it doesn't seem to be as predictably deflationary, and yet maybe it is, because, if someone is trying to make money off of holding a digital asset, doesn't it have to be deflationary? If the asset inflates, then people lose money and would have an incentive to spend it.

The other option seems to be stable coins, which somehow make me laugh, because many people in the space seem to be so against fiat currency and the US Fed, etc., and then create a currency tied directly to it and those policies.

Maybe I'm naive on this or just brainwashed by what I hear from the US Fed, it just seems that for a currency to work well, it has to almost be slightly inflationary, plus or minus a bit, so that people have an incentive to spend it more than save it.

Anyways, I'm glad you're working in this space and grateful for the way you shared with us :-)

Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by Abrownn on Saturday October 02, 2021 @05:29PM (#28732251)
Very neat, thanks for sharing. The name sounds familiar, I'm sure I've seen it mentioned alongside BAT in conversations about tipping creators. How's the adoption rate so far? Is there a development roadmap?
Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by simplify on Friday October 01, 2021 @03:27PM (#28722449)
Is there a demo I can interact with?
Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by xrd on Friday October 01, 2021 @03:37PM (#28722546)
Email me? [email protected]. I can set you up with a testnet. I'm in the end of a massive refactor, but I can give you that.
Re:Ask HN: Do you think web3 is a hype or a real thing about... by anilkuscu on Sunday October 03, 2021 @05:48AM (#28735832)
Can we solve the browser problem with webassembly ? What do you think about it ?