Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users
by avereveard on Friday October 01, 2021 @05:29PM
(#28723580)
I'm going to add smart contact providers have a strong incentive not to get the concept of smart contact tested in court, as if invalidated it would render them unfit for their purported use.
Other analogy that may be relevant are cases where casinos had slot machines with bugs awarding more prizes than the casino intended. In some cases/jurisdictions the courts ruled in favor of casinos, that the money was awarded incorrectly and should be returned; but in other cases/jurisdictions favored the winner, saying that the winner did everything right according to the rules of the game and should keep the winnings.
Also the Pepsi 349 Scandal in the Philippines in 1992 comes to mind [1]. In that case courts side with Pepsi, but I suspect that money has some inertia in Judges minds, so it was easy to side with Pepsi when it haven't paid yet. I suspect that if all that money had actually been automatically transfered to the many winners, then Pepsi would have a much harder task to convince the judges to make everyone transfer the money back.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pepsi_Number_Fever