In the road example, it's more like if every person paid for the ability to put one truck on the road and everyone delegated their truck space to a shipping company who now has millions of trucks hogging the roads. Yes, they're using tons of infrastructure but their usage has been paid for already.
If the ISP is selling me 1Gbps access to specific internet content only and I purchased the plan I use based on that knowledge[0] then charging me a toll for things that are outside of that specific internet content would be acceptable. But I didn't. I signed up for service that was limited only by speed, not consumption.
It's a little more evil than that, though. In a consumption/speed model, the two work against each other. I've paid a premium for 1Gps service over 300Mbps which results in me hitting that consumption barrier much faster, so I've paid for the privilege of getting hit with more "tolls". That's a hell of a profitable business model if you can get customers to actually do business with you.
Using a different analogy, the car wash company by ,y father's house offered $3/use car washes or a $30/month plan with hand-towel drying. It's a profitable arrangement for the car wash because most people won't wash their car ten times in a month. My dad, however, owned a company that sold products to automotive manufacturing plants and placed an unusually high value on having a very clean car. He took his car in for a wash every morning and many afternoons. That was the point of buying the $30 plan. For the car wash company to turn around and say "You're using your unlimited service so much that you're negatively affecting access to the car wash for our more profitable customers" would be illegal. That's not to say it doesn't happen all the time in other places, but it also doesn't mean we should allow it.
[0] And it's not OK for that to be buried in paragraph 11 of subparagraph a) in the user agreement as "abuse of network services".
Should the stadium pay the other town money to hold a game because lots of people there drive to watch it? Or should the other town build their roads to meet the demand of their citizens? I think the second option is more reasonable, the problem was that there wasn't enough road for the citizens in general, not that there wasn't enough road for them to watch this particular game.
Those trucks are only on the road because all the people in the houses keep ordering stuff online.
Should FedEx/UPS/Amazon have to pay an extra tax just because they are popular with the people? The homeowners already pay taxes to maintain the roads to their houses. Why should the city get extra from the trucking companies?
The public street network is in large parts paid for by taxes, so for everyone access to the network is already payed for.
If I now envision a single company blocking all streets with its giant truck fleet, I could completely understand a motion to introduce a new form of toll to be payed by such companies to avoid having to rise taxes.
That toll would most likely just increase the price of whatever said company is selling.