News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peter Thiel: The education of a libertarian (2009) by inglor_cz on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:21AM (#28716982)
This is a very generic statement. What would you single out as concrete examples?
Re:Peter Thiel: The education of a libertarian (2009) by rvense on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:33AM (#28717100)
In the fine article, he says that freedom and democracy are at odds. This rather bizarre conception of freedom is, I'm sure, the same thought that propelled him to f(o)und that well-know force for liberation of the common man, Palantir Technologies.

(There is, obviously, no real freedom for anyone without participation in the distribution of power, i.e. democracy.)

Re:Peter Thiel: The education of a libertarian (2009) by jokethrowaway on Friday October 01, 2021 @12:55PM (#28720826)
Democracy is granting power to the majority to rule on the minority. By definition.

Democracy will never create a free society, but neither will dictatorship. Democratic societies tend to be more free than dictatorship, but that's not always the case.

If there was an enlightened and rich dictator, he could decide to make weed legal, impose zero taxes, grant freedom of speech. Compared to most of the western world, where weed is mostly illegal, taxation is imposed forcefully and freedom of speech is disappearing - that would be a freer society.

The real way to have a freer society is to decentralise power away. It's not about granting 60 millions people an infinitesimal choice for an outcome shared by everyone. It's about each individual having a different outcome.

Re:Peter Thiel: The education of a libertarian (2009) by zoolily on Friday October 01, 2021 @01:15PM (#28721083)
Decentralization transfers powers to local elites, who are more likely to be interested in interfering with you or your group specifically compared to a more or less uncaring larger government. In the US, states weren't bound by the Bill of Rights until the 14th amendment, giving them more power to restrict liberties than the federal government. After reconstruction, SCOTUS issued decisions restoring much of the pre-war order, using the 14th amendment mainly to find new powers for corporations.
Re:Peter Thiel: The education of a libertarian (2009) by rvense on Friday October 01, 2021 @01:20PM (#28721159)
> Democracy is granting power to the majority to rule on the minority. By definition.

It really isn't. Maybe "Western-style, representative democracy" implies that. But democracy in general, to me, is any system where people rule themselves. I'm not really big on voting, for one.

> If there was an enlightened and rich dictator, he

would become a horrible authoritarian within six months, no matter how good his original intentions were.

> The real way to have a freer society is to decentralise power away.

I fully agree! The world needs more food co-ops and worker-owned businesses.

Re:Peter Thiel: The education of a libertarian (2009) by inglor_cz on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:40AM (#28717171)
Non-democratic states indeed tend to be non-free. But I think it is legitimate to think about extent of democracy vs. intrusion to personal lives.

It is probably fine to prevent someone from polluting water sources by a democratic vote.

It would be an overreach to prevent someone from grilling steaks on his porch because his neighbours are vegetarians and do not like the smell of meat.

Zoning of residential areas is somewhere in between.

Not too long ago, there was a case in Switzerland where a British person was denied citizenship by the initiative of her neighbors, because she complained too much about various topics (bells ringing too loudly etc.)

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/woman-annoyi...

Is it legitimate to take opinions of your neighbors into account when deciding your citizenship application? It is certainly more democratic than not doing so, but at the same time, it might degenerate into a popularity contest.

Re:Peter Thiel: The education of a libertarian (2009) by native_samples on Friday October 01, 2021 @03:12PM (#28722314)
The woman in question was Dutch, not British (the article says that in the first sentence). But really, she had lived in Switzerland for decades. Her children are Swiss, etc.
Re:Peter Thiel: The education of a libertarian (2009) by rvense on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:10AM (#28717417)
I never said democracy was easy. I just said it was necessary.
Re:Peter Thiel: The education of a libertarian (2009) by thinkski on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:51AM (#28717254)
Thomas Jefferson had similar thoughts, a “tyranny of the majority”. Say 1 in 100 people are doctors. People are tired of paying doctors and want care for free. They put it to a vote. 99 vote to force doctors to work for free. Democracy triumphs, but at what cost? This is partly why America was founded as a republic, not a pure democracy.
Re:Peter Thiel: The education of a libertarian (2009) by rvense on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:13AM (#28717445)
99 people forcing one person (or one thousand people) into slave labour does not satisfy my definition of democracy. Of course those that are more affected by an issue should have more of a say in it. Of course democracy must be founded on basic, inviolable rights. That's the whole point.
Re:Peter Thiel: The education of a libertarian (2009) by least on Friday October 01, 2021 @10:33AM (#28718934)
> ...does not satisfy my definition of democracy.

You can't just ignore the negative aspects of a system because it doesn't suit your sensibilities. Can you do the same for a system of government you're diametrically opposed to?

> Of course those that are more affected by an issue should have more of a say in it.

So you're fine with the electoral college then, right?

> Of course democracy must be founded on basic, inviolable rights. That's the whole point.

Not really. Democracy is simply a system to decide on policies that govern a group of people and there is little inherent value in it itself. It can be used to oppress just as easily as it can protect the rights of individuals living in the system. It's dependent on the voting population. Critics of democracy simply argue that it is too easy to oppress when you give individuals direct access to the power to do so.

Re:Peter Thiel: The education of a libertarian (2009) by rvense on Friday October 01, 2021 @01:05PM (#28720962)
> You can't just ignore the negative aspects of a system because it doesn't suit your sensibilities.

What I said was, if a system of government allows one group of people to turn another group of people into slaves, then it isn't a democracy. By my definition, a democracy does not allow slavery, because a democracy must treat all citizens equally.

> Democracy is simply a system to decide on policies that govern a group of people

To me it's more than that. It's a principle of governance. Not just the how of the system, but the why.

> So you're fine with the electoral college then, right?

You mean the American system for electing presidents? I don't know exactly, I am half a world away. I will say that from here that country looks pretty bad all in all, but the fact that a single person holds so much power seems a lot more problematic than how that person is picked - although it would be interesting to see what would happen if they somehow managed to find a good one. As far as I know that's never happened.

Re:Peter Thiel: The education of a libertarian (2009) by fighterpilot on Friday October 01, 2021 @10:29PM (#28725425)
> By my definition

You're using a different definition than Thiel is. His definition is simply a description of a system. If a country is a representative democracy or a direct democracy, where each person gets to vote, then it's a democracy by definition. Your definition pertains to an outcome of a system, such as equality. Neither of these are wrong definitions, since they're both commonly used in regular conversation, but you are talking at cross purposes.

Under his definition, which is what we should be talking about if we're addressing this in good faith, democracy (the system) and freedom are at odds because democracy is just majority rule. Women who can't get an abortion, rich people that have to give up 50% of their money, minorities that are discriminated against in law, victimless crimes being prosecuted (weed), and so on.

These are examples of the majority using their vote to strip the freedoms and property and time of other people.

Each day that I go to work, 1/2 of my day goes directly to the state, merely because a majority of the electorate thinks they are entitled to it. This isn't literal slavery (where 100% instead of 50% of my time is taken from me), but it's certainly not freedom when 1/2 of my productive energy is taken from me by threat of prison time if I do not comply.

Re:Peter Thiel: The education of a libertarian (2009) by least on Friday October 01, 2021 @05:43PM (#28723707)
> What I said was, if a system of government allows one group of people to turn another group of people into slaves, then it isn't a democracy. By my definition, a democracy does not allow slavery, because a democracy must treat all citizens equally.

Your 'definition' here doesn't coincide with reality, where a group may easily be oppressed by the majority. The fact that the example is at the most extreme does not invalidate that. Democracy does not require any sort of protections for those it is governing, just that they have a vote.

> To me it's more than that. It's a principle of governance. Not just the how of the system, but the why.

But it's not that. The principles you are ascribing to democracy are neither unique to nor a requirement for democracy. In fact quite frequently they are not. That is my point, people keep conflating democracy with these qualities that it does not possess. Advocate for those principles, not democracy.

Re:Peter Thiel: The education of a libertarian (2009) by jmeister on Friday October 01, 2021 @07:39AM (#28717158)
Did you want the Supreme Court to intervene in the democratically passed abortion law in TX?