Re:Treating beef like coal would make a big dent in greenhou...
by quantum_magpie on Friday October 01, 2021 @04:53AM
(#28716109)
For the most part, the CO2 absorption bands are already saturated -- increasing CO2 concentration has much less effect on transmission spectrum than that for methane.
Re:Treating beef like coal would make a big dent in greenhou...
by agilebodyshoppe on Friday October 01, 2021 @11:15AM
(#28719553)
the greenhouse effect is about internal reflections basically.
its the same effect that makes cloth appear darker when its wet even though water is basically colorless.
greenhouse gases bend light slightly, making it more likely that a light ray will hit the ground multiple times.
Re:Treating beef like coal would make a big dent in greenhou...
by dnautics on Friday October 01, 2021 @04:02PM
(#28722785)
This is a wrong answer if I've ever heard one.
Re:Treating beef like coal would make a big dent in greenhou...
by agilebodyshoppe on Friday October 01, 2021 @09:00PM
(#28725054)
seems like ive misunderstood this since i was a child. thank you for allowing me to embarrass myself in a safe environment.
Re:Treating beef like coal would make a big dent in greenhou...
by dnautics on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:28PM
(#28741787)
It's ok! Not all of us are atmospheric chemists! I certainly am not one.... Hence my lack of understanding.
Re:Treating beef like coal would make a big dent in greenhou...
by mongol on Friday October 01, 2021 @02:27AM
(#28715292)
Could it be something like how it is distributed in the atmosphere?
Re:Treating beef like coal would make a big dent in greenhou...
by dnautics on Friday October 01, 2021 @02:39AM
(#28715366)
I'm curious and hoping someone can explain it to me
Re:Treating beef like coal would make a big dent in greenhou...
by adrianN on Friday October 01, 2021 @02:47AM
(#28715415)
I'm just guessing: a) We don't have enough water in the atmosphere that the overlap with Methane meaningfully reduces net absorption, b) in the bands Methane absorbs there is more radiation available to absorb than in the CO2 band. If both are true that would explain the bigger effect of Methane.
Am I missing something? How can methane be a more potent GHG if it has lower IR absorption AND a shorter lifespan?
Edit: found spectra here (not the data that i took, obviously):
https://wattsupwiththat.files.wordpress.com/2014/04/methane_...
CO2 has a big fat band that blows out the absorption at 4.5 um in a region untouched by water (and one that is overwhelmed by water); methane has two spiky bands both of which are partially occluded by water.