Re:AWS Cloud Control API, a Uniform API to Access AWS and Th...
by 015a on Friday October 01, 2021 @12:01AM
(#28714353)
I think this is really similar to the "we use kubernetes so we don't get locked into AWS" argument; true in theory, never pans out in practice.
I'd hazard that the number of engineering orgs using a single Terraform "stack" (repository? domain? whatever) to manage resources across multiple providers is in the single-digit percentages.
The ability to transfer knowledge has non-zero benefit, but the reality is; that knowledge is 10% "Terraform & HCL", 90% "AWS Resource Configuration & Best Practices". 90% of it doesn't transfer, and most of the remaining 10% could be learned quickly enough.
Maybe it enables you to transfer CI/tooling between cloud providers should your org switch. Probably the most reasonable argument.
I think the core of what you're saying is actually right, for the same reasons that the kubernetes statement above is right; AWS is really becoming its own isolated world. Terraform on AWS makes less and less sense, as their in-house options like CF, CDK, SAM, etc evolve maturity beyond what TF is capable of. TF (and Pulumi) (like Kubernetes) is for everything else.
I'd hazard that the number of engineering orgs using a single Terraform "stack" (repository? domain? whatever) to manage resources across multiple providers is in the single-digit percentages.
The ability to transfer knowledge has non-zero benefit, but the reality is; that knowledge is 10% "Terraform & HCL", 90% "AWS Resource Configuration & Best Practices". 90% of it doesn't transfer, and most of the remaining 10% could be learned quickly enough.
Maybe it enables you to transfer CI/tooling between cloud providers should your org switch. Probably the most reasonable argument.
I think the core of what you're saying is actually right, for the same reasons that the kubernetes statement above is right; AWS is really becoming its own isolated world. Terraform on AWS makes less and less sense, as their in-house options like CF, CDK, SAM, etc evolve maturity beyond what TF is capable of. TF (and Pulumi) (like Kubernetes) is for everything else.