News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Death to the 'noreply' mailbox by FaceKicker on Thursday August 11, 2011 @12:40AM (#2871422)
> Hey asshole, what if I want to reply?

> What’s that? You don’t want crazies emailing you? You’re worried about spam?

Based on these lines, it seems like you're misunderstanding what "noreply@" means... They're not saying it's against the "rules" to reply, they're just saying nobody is monitoring the mailbox so it would be a waste of your time to do so. It's almost a courtesy, really...

Re:Death to the 'noreply' mailbox by 2arrs2ells on Thursday August 11, 2011 @12:47AM (#2871442)
You missed the point. The article is arguing that companies should put a monitored mailbox as the default reply-to, and not use unmonitored mailboxes, as they are missing out on valuable feedback and interactions.
Re:Death to the 'noreply' mailbox by stock_toaster on Thursday August 11, 2011 @12:54AM (#2871456)
I think for things where feedback is warranted, sure. But for automated email sending, alerts, notifications, things which may have very high bounce rates, using a real mailbox is basically spamming yourself or your support team.

I tend to use 'automated@' or 'a.robot@' though, to reflect that it was sent on behave of a process.

Re:Death to the 'noreply' mailbox by nodata on Thursday August 11, 2011 @12:59AM (#2871467)
But you won't know whether feedback is warranted. You don't get to decide - the user does.

As an example, yesterday I got an e-mail where a template variable hadn't been expanded. noreply means they don't get to find out. It's worth my time replying to an e-mail. It's not worth finding a contact form and filling it out.

Re:Death to the 'noreply' mailbox by capnrefsmmat on Thursday August 11, 2011 @12:58AM (#2871462)
Your reply-to address doesn't have to be the same as the envelope-from on the message, so intentional replies can go to a different address than SMTP bounces. You don't have to spam yourself.
Re:Death to the 'noreply' mailbox by FaceKicker on Thursday August 11, 2011 @01:14AM (#2871500)
I understand that point, and it's valid. I was only saying that the lines I quoted, from the way they are phrased, make the author seem like he doesn't understand the reason why businesses use "no-reply" addresses to begin with. Which I know wasn't the purpose of the article, but I thought it was worth bringing up.

Sorry if I misinterpreted.

Re:Death to the 'noreply' mailbox by RobertLowe on Thursday August 11, 2011 @12:53AM (#2871455)
You beat me too it.

I setup clients up with [email protected] when permitting. Turn those noreplies upsidedown ;)

[deleted]
Re:Death to the 'noreply' mailbox by avree on Thursday August 11, 2011 @12:57AM (#2871459)
From a flow perspective, lots of companies use automation tools/sorting for incoming e-mails. It's really easy to get inundated in e-mail spam, and it's hard to set up filtering on a very general e-mail with lots of possible "Reply" origins.