News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The seven programming ur-languages by mikewarot on Thursday September 30, 2021 @10:23PM (#28713811)
I'd add a few more entries

Excel - the spreadsheet model of programming has quite a bit of power that is hard to duplicate in other ways

Verilog/VHDL - Logic programming that happens all at once is a very important paradigm to know

Ladder Logic - The low level predecessor to the above, much like assembler is to C.

SQL - If you can't natively get data to/from a database from a command line tool, you're missing a very valuable toolset.

Other things I've come across of note:

TKsolver! - The version 1 ran on MS-DOS, and could find what ever variables weren't supplied from those that were, by working backwards through equations.

Metamine - this appeared and winked out of existence, the main feature was the ability to do a "magical assignment" that reactively updated the left side throughout the life of the program, and had sane provisions for dealing with both normal and magical assignments in the same program.

STOICAL - A forth variant that did data types, lists, queues, dictionaries and hashes along with the usual forth stuff. The author moved on to write DAW, an audio editor. Unfortunately, it's in C, and makes a lot of 32 bit assumptions that I don't know enough to fix.

GNU Radio - If you want to learn DSP without the math, install this, and play with your audio inputs and outputs, and work your way up from there. You build flowgraphs, and they compile/run in real time.

Re:The seven programming ur-languages by watersb on Friday October 01, 2021 @12:15AM (#28714464)
Excellent...

Ladder logic, or "Linear Programming" usually implements state machines for industrial control systems.

Constraint systems like TKsolver! are sort of like Prolog, maybe.

Spreadsheets: reminded me of a similar but different beast, the scriptable outline programs. Dave Winer's UserLand Frontier is maybe the best example.

Omni Software's OmniFocus product grew from Ethan Schoenover's beast of a script system that he built in Omni's outliner product.

Is industrial "Operations Research" computer programming? Or is it just in a bigger bag, alongside the computers, called "Cybernetics"?

Re:The seven programming ur-languages by sidpatil on Friday October 01, 2021 @03:09AM (#28715542)
I'm not sure how linear programming has anything to do with ladder logic. Did you mean to put it next to constraint programming, which it does have more in common with?
Re:The seven programming ur-languages by watersb on Friday October 01, 2021 @05:44PM (#28723714)
Yes: oops. Linear programming as constraint solving. Thanks!

I have not actually done any ladder logic; it seemed to be like flow charts or network transaction diagrams...

I should not post so much when tired. But your great comments got me thinking about all of the ways that we approach programming in non-lexical ways, be that with a graphical formal analysis like Yourdon/Coad or (shudder) Rational Rose, or more direct translation like (ouch) UML, or just wireframes and story boards when hashing things out with a client.

Perhaps all of that is wildly off-topic; they all distill down into written code, usually in one of the "7 ur-languages".

Re:The seven programming ur-languages by CRConrad on Tuesday October 05, 2021 @01:59AM (#28755935)
> Excel - the spreadsheet model of programming has quite a bit of power that is hard to duplicate in other ways

Aargh -- at least frigging call it VisiCalc, please. Or improve on it, drop the final -e, and call it "Improv". Either way, please don't contribute to (or are you yourself suffering from?) the current pandemic of thinking "spreadsheet" is synonymous with "Excel".