News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by rsynnott on Thursday September 30, 2021 @10:46AM (#28706924)
I can see that the idea that it was a lab leak could be _reassuring_ to people; "this just happened and could happen again at any time" is a way scarier prospect than "this happened due to negligence and can be prevented from happening again with better procedures", and people do tend to over-index on explanations which offer solutions.

Notably, you got a lot of the same sort of thing (albeit way more conspiracy-ish, because HIV's origins were far clearer) for HIV.

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by kcplate on Thursday September 30, 2021 @04:14PM (#28710793)
> I can see that the idea that it was a lab leak could be _reassuring_ to people;

To me its less reassuring. It tells me that us humans actively sought out pathogens in spaces where it was unlikely that humans would encounter them otherwise. Then took those pathogens to a lab, experimented on them a bit perhaps making them more deadly, have shitty security protocols for the experiment, and thereby releasing them accidentally into a large population.

A lab leak makes it our fault and speaks to the stupidity of us humans. A zoological origin makes it natures fault. I’d much rather nature kill me by accident (besides I think our odds are better).

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by rsynnott on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:15AM (#28717454)
Sure, but all of that is _addressable_, via improved standards. That is, if one buys the lab leak theory, it's practical to stop it happening again. But if it was normal zoonotic transmission, well, there are ways to make that somewhat less likely, but it will happen again; diseases make the jump from time to time, and realistically this avenue for new diseases can't be shut down.
Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by kcplate on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:08PM (#28724770)
Improved standards may help some, but that’s not the real issue. If I, a virologist, enter a remote cave system that no other human would likely ever enter specifically looking for an undiscovered virus to study, I have already tipped the scales significantly to the likelihood that the unknown virus will infect humans by a huge scale over nature.

Then, by experimentation, I make said virus even more infectious or deadly…I have even further increased that likelihood of it infecting humans by a huge factor.

Then, by performing that experiment in an area with a dense 11M population, I have further increased that likelihood of human transmission so far beyond where it was when that virus sat in that remote cave and had a unlikely path to humans.

So you better hope like hell that your lab security is bulletproof, because you have removed virtually every layer of protection that nature has provided us humans from the bug.

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by saalweachter on Thursday September 30, 2021 @11:01AM (#28707146)
> "The question of the origin of COVID-19 isn’t of merely academic interest. The answer could guide the world’s preparation for future pandemics; if the virus emerged from a laboratory, then improving lab safety measures will be prioritized. If scientific opinion continues to coalesce around animal-to-human transmission, that will underscore the importance of regulating contact between humans and wildlife."
Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by rsynnott on Thursday September 30, 2021 @03:43PM (#28710451)
So I think the difference is, in the lab leak scenario, that's relatively _easy_ to solve; it's just a case of increasing standards in a rather small number of facilities. If it's zoonotic transition, well, it's all very well to say "underscore the importance of regulating contact between humans and wildlife", but, er, good luck with that. That doesn't offer a real solution.