News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by junon on Thursday September 30, 2021 @09:19AM (#28705953)
Unpopular comment on HN I'm sure, but I know a few people who work in various infectious diseases labs - one of which sits in with policy makers and is one of the referred to when those officials talk about their "expert advisors".

None of them believe it was a lab leak. All of them believe it was a spill over or a wet market incident.

Anecdotal, I'm aware. But I'm personally yielding to those people who work in the same building as the world's deadliest diseases, who have all of the information and have all of their (usually multiple) degrees.

Lab leak is juicy. It would give us someone to blame. That's human nature to want it to be true. But nothing I've heard aside from news outlets and conspiracy theorists gives me any reason to believe it's a lab leak.

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by mizzack on Thursday September 30, 2021 @09:25AM (#28706010)
Lab leak, if true, would be damaging to the flexibility of their work and bring further scrutiny toward future funding of said work.

They have incentive for it to not be true.

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by junon on Thursday September 30, 2021 @09:46AM (#28706249)
No, it wouldn't. They're not the ones who had the leak, if true.
Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by baja_blast on Thursday September 30, 2021 @11:22AM (#28707400)
yes it would, just because it just so happened to take place at another lab does not mean the public and regulators are going to ignore the dangerous research other labs are conducting. No one wants to be the next Wuhan, but it's only a matter of time until the next coincidence happens in a city with a major lab.

A lab origin could not only tank their future prospects due to massive restrictions and funding bans, but it would also severely stigmatize their profession. They'll be viewed as Frankenstiens

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by junon on Thursday September 30, 2021 @01:14PM (#28708670)
I think you grossly misunderstand how infectious disease research works.
Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by linuxftw on Thursday September 30, 2021 @09:29AM (#28706058)
There's an alleged whistleblower that says it's a lab leak. Someone that was on the ground and had access to information. That's not a conspiracy theory. Whether or not you believe this person, that's up to you.
Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by junon on Thursday September 30, 2021 @09:48AM (#28706260)
Contrary to popular belief (it seems), not all scientists are in cahoots with all other scientists worldwide. Especially not those in China.

So yes, I believe this person (these people, actually) as they are both close friends and some of the smartest people I know.

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by linuxftw on Thursday September 30, 2021 @09:51AM (#28706283)
Just because you believe them and they're smart, doesn't mean they have all the information. So, you can take the opinion of people that weren't physically present at the lab, or you can take the account of a whistleblower who claims to have been physically present and part of an investigation.
Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by junon on Thursday September 30, 2021 @09:55AM (#28706340)
That's a bizarre and entirely unrealistic dichotomy. I could make a similar one for the other side of the debate, too. But I'll refrain because it's not how scientific discourse should work.
Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by linuxftw on Thursday September 30, 2021 @10:04AM (#28706443)
You're choosing to ignore a whistle blower because it conflicts with your friends opinions, opinions that aren't most likely 1st hand accounts.

If you're expecting an organization to just willfully admit negligence or wrong doing, especially if they took actions to cover it up (according to the whistle blower), when has that EVER happened?

Do we have the lab records and transaction logs? Are those records able to be tampered with easily? Who, that has subpoena power, is actually investigating? Does anyone have the power to carry out an actual investigation?

I don't understand why you're placing your faith in a political system.

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by junon on Thursday September 30, 2021 @01:17PM (#28708711)
> You're choosing to ignore a whistle blower

I'm choosing to be skeptical of a single person's claim. I never said I ignored them.

> because it conflicts with your friends opinions

No, because my friends' expert conclusions based on all of the available data conflicts with the "word" of a single, anonymous source. There's nothing that states whistleblowers are telling the truth or that they can be trusted.

> If you're expecting an organization to just willfully admit negligence or wrong doing, especially if they took actions to cover it up (according to the whistle blower), when has that EVER happened?

That's beside the point I made to begin with. I don't see how it's relevant. The dealings of the CCP do not change how SARS-COVID-2 is structured.

> I don't understand why you're placing your faith in a political system.

I am, expressly, not doing that. I'm placing faith in people who understand infectious diseases more than some random person on Hacker News - and more than myself, at that.

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by linuxftw on Thursday September 30, 2021 @01:43PM (#28708988)
The whistle blower is named and public, not anonymous.

> I'm placing faith in people who understand infectious diseases more than some random person on Hacker News - and more than myself, at that.

You're choosing to listen to your friend's opinion, who probably doesn't possess any material facts.

> how SARS-COVID-2 is structured

That's really not at issue here, I think you're addressing a strawman that I didn't make.

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by junon on Thursday September 30, 2021 @02:08PM (#28709225)
> The whistle blower is named and public, not anonymous.

Okay, and my point still stands.

> who probably doesn't possess any material facts.

Why do you make such strong assertions/assumptions when you have no idea to whom I'm referring?

> That's really not at issue here, I think you're addressing a strawman that I didn't make.

Not really, no. I don't think you're really making good points to begin with.

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by linuxftw on Thursday September 30, 2021 @02:24PM (#28709434)
> Why do you make such strong assertions/assumptions when you have no idea to whom I'm referring?

Because you could have already easily said "I know someone with 1st hand information from the place in question" but you didn't, so it seems strongly likely you don't.

What information would you actually be willing to consider to change your point of view? It seems unlikely at this point anything resembling an actual investigation will ever take place, so the best we have is a whistle blower.

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by moate on Thursday September 30, 2021 @09:34AM (#28706106)
Let's break down the phrase:

"Conspiracy": A secret plan by a group to do something unlawful or harmful; the action of plotting or conspiring.

"Theory": A supposition or a system of ideas intended to explain something, especially one based on general principles independent of the thing to be explained.

What you're offering is a conspiracy theory. It's a possible explanation for an event that alleges a conspiracy (either the cover up of an accidental leak or malicious intentional leak).

Adding "do your own research/it's up to you to believe" at the end of a conspiracy theory doesn't make it not a conspiracy theory.

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by josephcsible on Thursday September 30, 2021 @09:44AM (#28706222)
The phrase "conspiracy theory" carries baggage beyond that of the individual definitions of the two words.
Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by moate on Thursday September 30, 2021 @02:16PM (#28709332)
Oh I get that, but that's my point.

Saying "this isn't a conspiracy theory because that phrase has negative connotations I don't want associated with MY conspiracy theory" isn't going to make it not a conspiracy theory.

I firmly believe Epstein didn't kill himself. I'm aware it's a conspiracy theory. Let's call a spade a spade.

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by linuxftw on Thursday September 30, 2021 @09:48AM (#28706261)
Here's a 'conspiracy theory:' I think org XYZ is doing nefarious things because X happened and it's in their best interest to cover it up.

See, there's no first hand evidence, there's just raw speculation.

A whistleblower, on the other hand, claims to have a 1st hand account of nefarious or at the least misleading actions of a particular entity.

I didn't offer any theories. The person making the claim isn't offering theories, they're offering first hand accounts. If you say this person is lying for political purposes, it's you who's creating a conspiracy theory.

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by moate on Thursday September 30, 2021 @02:19PM (#28709373)
Sometimes I like to use the following example when it comes to semantics and discourse: If you start a sentence with the phrase "This isn't a sex thing, but..." no matter what you say afterwards will be interpreted as having possible sexual meanings.

If you want to frame something by saying it's not something else, people will make the connection. Why? Because you made it for them.

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by linuxftw on Thursday September 30, 2021 @04:24PM (#28710903)
The first one to mention conspiracy theory was the poster I originally responded to (possibly you?). When I read "conspiracy theory" I think to myself "this person gets their facts from CNN and no place else." Just ignore the man behind the curtain.
Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by JohnJamesRambo on Thursday September 30, 2021 @09:25AM (#28706011)
I already have someone to blame and it was a President too stupid to wear a mask that sent thousands to their deaths. A president that instigated an era of not believing the news or experts and introduced a culture of “alternate facts”, otherwise known as lies, that have caused the current anti-vaccine idiocy.

695,000 Americans dead so far.

Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by Ekaros on Thursday September 30, 2021 @04:30PM (#28710961)
Maybe if news weren't hell bent on personal attacks disregarding any truth things might be different... I entirely blame media, I think most of them should be banned from operating.
Re:New evidence undermines the Covid lab-leak theory by junon on Thursday September 30, 2021 @09:47AM (#28706253)
That has nothing to do with my point.