I have been using HN since 2012, and have over 4000 karma spread over three accounts, but sometimes downvotes still flummox me. I think as long as a user seems respectful, a little meta discussion is okay in order to learn how to be a better user going forward.
Yes, some people are obnoxious and obviously toxic, and when they complain about being downvoted, they should definitely be downvoted more, but when a user seems genuinely curious, I think we should do our part to help make HN a better place by taking a moment to give a quick reason.
I've politely asked in the past in order to not make the same mistake again. I think we should give users the benefit of doubt.
> Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.
However
> Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading.
I think that last guideline should be changed to "Please don't complain about the voting on comments."
Why not allow meta-discussions? If HN is striving to be a place where interesting topics can be discussed, then I suppose commenting etiquette should fall under that heading for sure.
That would be understandable if you presented an unpopular opinion at first, and your subsequent posting was trying to defend it. But even when the second posting is not in the same line as the original one, it often gets hammered down just as much.
I'm sure others might have observed the same effect?