News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by ravar on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @12:34PM (#28696098)
never mind that many of the positions that are "scientific consensus" are not supported by the current peer reviewed research.
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by newswasboring on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @12:50PM (#28696360)
A few examples would be nice to understand what you are saying.
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by CodeMage on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @12:49PM (#28696324)
That's honestly news to me. I thought that "scientific consensus" is supported by peer-reviewed research, by definition. Can you elaborate?
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by stickfigure on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @01:02PM (#28696552)
Not the parent, but this study seems to be the best RCT of mask effectiveness so far (N=350,000):

https://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2021/09/surgical-mask...

Cloth masks showed no statistically significant reduction in the spread of Covid-19. (surgical masks - different story)

Yet I'm still surrounded by people - wearing predominantly cloth masks - that are full of outrage for the maskless. I've not heard any updates from the CDC on this issue.

Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by Drew_ on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @01:22PM (#28696902)
> Cloth masks showed no statistically significant reduction in the spread of Covid-19.

This is a completely false characterization of the article you just linked.

There were significantly fewer COVID-19 cases in villages with surgical masks compared with the control villages. (Although there were also fewer COVID-19 cases in villages with cloth masks as compared to control villages, the difference was not statistically significant.) This aligns with lab tests showing that surgical masks have better filtration than cloth masks. However, cloth masks did reduce the overall likelihood of experiencing symptoms of respiratory illness during the study period.

“Unfortunately, much of the conversation around masking in the United States is not evidence-based,” Luby said. “Our study provides strong evidence that mask wearing can interrupt the transmission of SARS-CoV-2. It also suggests that filtration efficiency is important. This includes the fit of the mask as well as the materials from which it is made. A cloth mask is certainly better than nothing. But now might be a good time to consider upgrading to a surgical mask.”

Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by stickfigure on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @01:42PM (#28697211)
From the original paper:

--- We find clear evidence that surgical masks lead to a relative reduction in symptomatic seroprevalence of 11.2% (aPR = 0.89 [0.78,1.00]; control prevalence = 0.80%; treatment prevalence = 0.71%). For cloth masks, we find an imprecise zero, although the confidence interval includes the point estimate for surgical masks (aPR = 0.95 [0.79,1.11]; control prevalence 0.67%; treatment prevalence 0.62%). ---

If you go to the chart, you find a 5% relative reduction with a p-value of 0.540 (!)

Regarding reduction in symptoms:

--- Additionally, when we look separately by cloth and surgical masks, we find that the intervention led to a reduction in COVID-like symptoms under either mask type (p = 0.000 for surgical, p = 0.048 for cloth), but the effect size in surgical mask villages was 30-80% larger depending on the specification. In Table A10, we run the same specifications using the smaller sample used in our symptomatic seroprevalence regression (i.e. those who consented to give blood). In this sample we continue to find an effect overall and an effect for surgical masks, but see no effect for cloth masks. ---

There's no intellectually honest way to interpret this data other than "cloth masks have very little effect, if any".

Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by LudvigVanHassen on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @01:35PM (#28697105)
Emphasizing this quote:

However, cloth masks did reduce the overall likelihood of experiencing symptoms of respiratory illness during the study period.

Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by wepple on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @01:15PM (#28696762)
This is really interesting, and I’d like to read the paper - do you have a link?

EDIT: here: https://www.poverty-action.org/publication/impact-community-...

That summary is really hard to draw conclusions from;

“However, cloth masks did reduce the overall likelihood of experiencing symptoms of respiratory illness during the study period.”

And “ A cloth mask is certainly better than nothing. But now might be a good time to consider upgrading to a surgical mask.”

But also “ Although there were also fewer COVID-19 cases in villages with cloth masks as compared to control villages, the difference was not statistically significant.”

Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by DenisM on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @05:26PM (#28700175)
I suppose it means there was a difference but it was not statistically significant. Like 5% reduction with 10% certainty.
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by deusexml on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @01:13PM (#28696734)
This is not true. The study found a reduction in COVID-19 symptoms for the cloth mask group. They also found a reduction in seroprevalence for the cloth mask group, but that reduction wasn't statistically significant. "Statistically insignificant" is not the same as "not true". It is very hard to sufficiently power a seroprevalence study.
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by stickfigure on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @01:29PM (#28697009)
This is a high-power study with N in the hundreds of thousands.

"Statistically insignificant" is the same as "no reason to believe it is true".

Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by virtuallynathan on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @12:52PM (#28696385)
There’s quite a few medical practices which guidelines still recommend that do not show benefit in better or newer trials.

https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/1104821

Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by newswasboring on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @01:00PM (#28696512)
This paper says we should abandon practices when they are shown to not work. I don't think anyone will disagree with that. But the original post made it seem like there were practices which were adopted willy nilly. But this paper just shows the self correcting nature of science.
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by virtuallynathan on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @01:14PM (#28696747)
They had to write a paper saying that because it doesn’t happen. We are still doing these procedures today.

Do the interventional cardiologists want to stop stenting people? Not really. The orthopedic surgeons still want to mess with your meniscus, etc.

Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by newswasboring on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @02:00PM (#28697477)
I mean... This is the scientific framework. There was a mistake and the mechanism to fix it is to write more papers. I know it's not fixed yet, but that's the procedure. Do you believe this should never have happened? Then I guess we disagree on how powerful human intellect can be.
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by virtuallynathan on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @03:54PM (#28699058)
I think its fine for this to occur, and we should expect it, but how long should it take to reverse a bad practice? Is a decade or more acceptable?
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by newswasboring on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @04:12PM (#28699261)
Of course not. Nobody is endorsing for that. The problem is these are hard problems to solve and forming a consensus is a hard problem in addition to it. If we keep flip flopping on every new data point we will have more misses than hits.
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by yawboakye on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @01:16PM (#28696779)
It's a sad sign of the times that "scientific consensus" doesn't sound crazy anymore. It was scientific consensus that the Catholic church based on to sentence Galileo. He was a lone dissenting voice. A bit of history for you. And this is besides the fact that true scientists have never sought consensus/peer-review. I'll stand by as you come up with non-modern, paper-churning, publish-or-perish examples of great scientists famous (or great) for work or theory that was accepted by means of consensus.
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by nemo on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @01:43PM (#28697224)
There's no Catholic Church prosecuting those who defy the official scientific position today. Galileo was not a lone dissenting voice - he was a proponent of Copernicanism, which he overstated the accuracy of his evidence for, feuding with the Church about whether he was overstating, and getting himself in terrible trouble with the Church. Once Kepler's models were confirmed with observations after Galileo with better telescopes the Church accepted. Later Enlightenment thinkers built a martyr myth around Galileo, and today the nature of his conflict with the Church is an ahistorical picture painted by later hagiographies of Galileo

This is a story that does not apply to our times. There've been many regular scientific revolutions even in the last few decades, the Church hasn't persecuted scientists, and the modern scientific consensus has followed with the revolutions. Whether it's the matter of the cause of the Cretaceous–Paleogene extinction, the revolutions in molecular biology, revolutions in astronomy, or other areas where advances are regular, those outliers actually advancing science have only briefly been ahead of consensus in the real world, but most outliers are cranks, and only those with an expert training in a discipline are likely to be able to identify real advances over crank science. The Galileo model of believing outliers virtually always leaves you in the wrong unless you are a domain-specific expert on the topic.

Look at using MRNA as a medical treatment as another example of a recent revolution, one that's now available in a safe, effective vaccine form.

Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by yawboakye on Thursday September 30, 2021 @03:02AM (#28703887)
On scientific consensus delivering the goods, here you seem to have it backwards (or our experiences of how science is conducted differs fundamentally). To my knowledge, one person and one experiment (usually, except where the product is purely mathematical) is enough to propose a new theory (but also to refute an existing one). If a debunked theory was supported by scientific consensus (ie theory wasn't standing on its own), what happens to the consensus it merited? and the so-called scientists who "voted?" Or perhaps the scientific consensus was just paperweight?

Scientific consensus provides a means for bad science/scientists to escape ostracism (I use this with the full intensity of its definitions). Because it provides a thick and opaque veil behind which the clergy (all scientists) instructs the laity (the rest of us). Individual scientists no longer stand and fall on their own. So call them cranks if you want but the individuals standing on the banks of the "scientific consensus" stream are arguably the closest we have to 16th and 17th century scientists tinkering away in their private labs, making discoveries that continue to bear their names.

Now, to a philosophy of science I subscribe to: Popper's Falsifiability Test. An undercurrent (probably prominent, even) theme is this: new confirmatory experiments add nothing new if they don't deviate materially from the original experiment. Following this, the whole enterprise of scientific consensus stands on shaky grounds since it adds nothing. It transforms science into a faith-based exercise (akin to bishops at a synod throwing their weights behind certain theories and declaring other bishops as cranks/heretics). This I do not accept.

Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by nemo on Thursday September 30, 2021 @10:23AM (#28706664)
>To my knowledge, one person and one experiment (usually, except where the product is purely mathematical) is enough to propose a new theory (but also to refute an existing one).

To my knowledge theories proposed that way in modern science aren't taken seriously and in our present time are not the norm for any recent major scientific discoveries or research. Those days are long past. New science is done in expensive labs with very expensive equipment and gets funded by grants. The Alvarez Hypothesis was possible because of cutting edge nuclear science that could identify the iridium. LIGO, and every space science and astronomical discovery are driven by really expensive ever growing scopes. In astronomy, chem, physics, molecular biology, paleontology, et al today you'll need an expensive lab and very large grants to do cutting edge work. At this point we're building colliders many kilometers in length. Modern Science is a product of well funded labs with staffing and equipment funded largely by research grants. There are cases in domains like macrobiology where individuals could do field work and find a new species, but the domains where the individual scientist is doing meaningful work are dwindling to none, and you should update your model of how modern science actually operates and is funded, it's interesting.

Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by yawboakye on Thursday September 30, 2021 @11:31AM (#28707528)
This isn't an argument in favor of scientific consensus. There's no straight path between expensive, collaborative research/science and scientific consensus. If anything the units of science have moved from individuals to teams acting as a body. But this isn't scientific consensus.
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by yawboakye on Thursday September 30, 2021 @02:40AM (#28703790)
I'll try to answer in two parts. First you seem to have missed the point that (1) the Church was no (or rather accidental) arbiter of science—they largely deferred to the prevailing consensus. Thus in the conflict with Galileo, they were upholding a status quo which itself was upheld on the foundation of "many scientists believe that …" ie scientific consensus. You have a point if you say that Galileo wasn't a lone dissenting voice but then you'd have to explain what it was exactly that silenced Rene Descartes from publishing (as he confessed). He self-censored out of fear of contradicting the Church's position. If you bear in mind that the Church conducted no scientific experiments, Descartes essentially wasn't comfortable going up against the consensus.
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by nemo on Thursday September 30, 2021 @10:39AM (#28706856)
The Church did hold the consensus opinion, and accepted the minority opinion, Copernicanism, as a hypothesis. At that time, the epicycic systems made better predictions than Heliocentrism with round orbits. Kepler's later elliptical models did fit and won out after Galileo's day. Also, while Galileo presented some compelling evidence from astronomical observations, he was the only one able to make them, which made his claims difficult to confirm. He stated that Copernicanism was not a hypothesis, the Church tried to get him to walk that back, but Galileo bitterly feuded with an initially sympathetic, but ultimately hostile Pope Urban VIII enough to get himself in trouble. He was persecuted for defying the pope, the science was only a proximate cause to the root cause of his problem which was that he was rude to the pope.

That points to a bad system, but one that has nothing to do with the modern world we live in, and which if applied by analogy will fit so poorly as to be a bad analogy.

Also the Church conducted scientific experiments regularly, since a number of priests through the ages were scientists, and it was a result of priests taking observations in later, better telescopes that updated the Church's position on heliocentrism.

Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by yawboakye on Thursday September 30, 2021 @11:28AM (#28707488)
We don't disagree on all the factors leading up to Galileo's prosecution. But we should be careful judging why he was rude to the establishment. AFAIK it had all to do with the orthodoxy, not personal ongoing grudge. It's the same visceral rejection we have for obviously wrong/broken processes. The papacy around this time was in the throes of more urgent & existential problems, and so reaching for the huge mallet to kill Galileo once and for all made the most sense. Scientific consensus was that hammer.

That aside, individual priest carried out their experiments, not in the name of the Church. The Church had already leaned towards scholarship by this time (post-Bologna) and being the dominant component of all European cultures, it only made sense that it would attract people with interests in science and experiments. (By the time we had scientist-priests people didn't know why they were Christians, to begin with.) This is discounting roles in Church or its bodies—usually monasteries—that required a vow to dumbness.

Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by alentist on Friday October 01, 2021 @12:09PM (#28720250)
> By the time we had scientist-priests people didn't know why they were Christians, to begin with.

What do you mean?

Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by yawboakye on Sunday October 03, 2021 @07:05AM (#28736193)
Christianity had become culture.
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by alentist on Sunday October 03, 2021 @02:03PM (#28739128)
You mean ubiquitous? So? That's a non-sequitur.
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by yawboakye on Sunday October 03, 2021 @04:10PM (#28740118)
I don't mean ubiquitous. I know what ubiquitous means. Latin wasn't ubiquitous in Rome. A thing of culture isn't ubiquitous. If anything it was transparent. Perhaps you should read about the era under observation before attempting to summarise/reinterpret?
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by alentist on Monday October 04, 2021 @05:04AM (#28744625)
Perhaps you should attempt to substantiate your nonsensical claim?
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by yawboakye on Monday October 04, 2021 @01:49PM (#28750072)
Perhaps you need a dictionary?
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by alentist on Wednesday October 06, 2021 @05:20AM (#28770890)
I don't. Perhaps you do? Are you unable to substantiate your nonsensical claim?
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by ravar on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @04:24PM (#28699432)
Call it the church of Google(Faang?) if you will. They have real power over peoples lives and livelihoods. The church of Faang has a nice ring to it.
Re:YouTube is banning anti-vaccine activists and blocking al... by nemo on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @05:42PM (#28700372)
Google/FAANG have no real point of control anywhere in the process of how the sciences operate. Scientists publish in journals, while social media, search, et al. are handy but not something that guides their research or their consensus.

The real gatekeeping comes in what research gets grants and funding, but if you look into what's happening there, it's not comparable to the Church proscribing things - it mostly means that the DoD, petrochem, and a few industries have outsized influence on what research is done.