News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spaces launch in Element by nyanpasu64 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @03:30PM (#28686480)
A week ago, I noticed that Element Desktop was starting to hide "rooms in spaces" from my home screen, which now only contains rooms not in a space.

I really don't like how Element Android has you separately pick which space to view (in the sidebar), and whether to look at DMs or rooms (in the bottom bar). Now I often end up picking the KDE space, but only showing DMs, which results in an empty view (because I've only joined KDE-related chats, not KDE-related DMs).

I think I'd prefer a list of spaces where I can set rules for what goes where. For example, I want to create a space called "Contacts", where I first manually pin my "self-room" for note-taking and test messages to the top, then ask Element to add all DMs I'm in, ordered by "most recent" or manual order. Then I want a space called KDE where I place specific KDE-related rooms inside. Then have a space called "Rooms" with the leftover non-KDE rooms.

In the process, I'd remove the Android client's bottom DM/room selector (unsure what to do with the notification tab), replace it with 2 "default spaces" in the left sidebar (one for DMs and the other for rooms, but with user-customizable rules), and let user-created spaces coexist alongside the two default spaces.

The end result would work something like a hybrid of Telegram's automatic rules, Discord's single DM namespace followed by a server list, and Matrix's current spaces system. Unfortunately, it seems Element has officially released the Spaces feature, ignoring (or not even seeing) my feedback a week ago in the Matrix HQ room. I don't know if they're still accepting changes to how spaces operate.

Re:Spaces launch in Element by throwawayIxZCg on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @04:51PM (#28687336)
> I really don't like how Element Android has you separately pick which space to view (in the sidebar), and whether to look at DMs or rooms (in the bottom bar). Now I often end up picking the KDE space, but only showing DMs, which results in an empty view (because I've only joined KDE-related chats, not KDE-related DMs).

Yes, switching between a DM in one space and a room in another takes at least one tap too many. Hopefully this paragraph in the article expresses the intention to work on this:

> Clearer interfaces: To make Spaces, Rooms, People, Direct Messages, Favourites and your conversation history easy to find over time, every time.

Re:Spaces launch in Element by novocaine on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:41PM (#28687878)
Great suggestions - thanks.

The information architecture of Spaces as presented in Element isn't perfect, and is at the top of the list of improvements we'd like to make as we iterate on the feature.

Releasing out of beta doesn't mean we intend to stop iterating on Spaces - it simply means we think the feature brings enough value to share it with everyone and open it up to the whole user base for feedback.

Re:Spaces launch in Element by callahad on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:39PM (#28687863)
> Element Desktop was starting to hide "rooms in spaces" from my home screen, which now only contains rooms not in a space.

To change this behavior, enable "Show all rooms in Home" under Settings > Appearance

Re:Spaces launch in Element by nyanpasu64 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @11:49PM (#28690117)
I don't see such an option on Arch Linux, guess I'll wait for the next update to arrive.