That same system was implemented on the company's website later on, which didn't make me feel any better. To top it all off, they never even replied.
B) How do you know they programmed that app with thousands of users even remotely well? Did they store passwords in plaintext? Does it need to be reboot every 5 mins? Is it slow as molasses, but hidden behind load balancing?
Someone could have written awesome sites with 1000s of users and loads of revenue, but it might still have been done like crap, and doesn't belong anywhere on your network.
B) I ask them questions about the implementation.
You can get a feel for whether the candidate can program a simple blog by asking them how they'd do it, you don't have to ask them to spend hours actually doing the nitty-gritty...