The systems basically direct user work, so you have a pretty good level of detail, particularly as users will also often scan to tell the system when they are doing other stuff for instance breaks:
* Go to location X (User scans barcode) * Take 2 of item and confirm (User scans barcode on each of the two items) * Now go to location Y (User scans barcode) * Take 1 of item and confirm (User presses not-found) * Now go to location Z (User scans lunch break barcode) * Please scan lunch break finished when complete (User scans lunch break complete) * Now go to location Z (User scans location) * Take 1 of item and confirm (and so on)
Each prompt and response is recorded as a transaction in the WMS, and then the total time estimate is calculated afterwards based on those transactions.
> That is, very few people are noticeably better than the median worker. But many people just don't work at all
Absenteeism is a huge problem - you are absolutely right! Yeah, it can be easy to hide in a giant DC. Regardless of how good of a manager you are and how much you walk around, if an associate decided to spend their full shift hidden behind some pallets reading a book, it would be really hard to notice their absence without seeing that they picked nothing on the system (particularly when you have a team of 30!).
Good note on the scoping of the tasks - it depends totally on the implementation! Ours was pretty good, but the difficulty was keeping it up to date as you have to change the walk routes and distances any time you move physical equipment on site, or change site rules/physical processes.
I've never gotten to work with an activity level system, just overall daily or larger outcomes.
A lot of the conversations were bonus related too - “Hey, FYI you are scraping the bonus threshold so if you really smash it across the next 3 days you can pocket an extra $200 or so”.
Maybe this is different? Hard to say. But if I were to guess, I would imagine the differences in individual performance that are truly due to employee agency are not that high.
> We are talking about observing staff in a 1 million sqft warehouse across 5 floors of mezzanine, in a maze of aisles, and also the manager and associates shift patterns could be different - it's just impossible. I was a department manager (not for Amazon) and it's just impossible to eyeball picker performance in any sort of fair way, you have to look at data.
And I tend to imagine (perhaps uninformed) that these systems don't catch any small details. Presuming these people do in fact have managers, the big picture assessment of whether they're totally slacking off vs. working normally is likely to be apparent without data. The amount of actual agency people have in a task like this, I'd imagine, is heavily skewed left. That is, very few people are noticeably better than the median worker. But many people just don't work at all. Absenteeism is a problem in a lot of jobs like these, including pre-COVID. A large part of it is just getting people to show up.