Re:A notable JavaScript developer shamelessly copied one of ...
by hitekker on Monday September 27, 2021 @06:22PM
(#28676802)
The difference is that someone pirated another person's software and tried to get away with it. Then that person's fan club wrote a bunch of nonsense to distract, deflect and cloud their malfeasance.
Attribution may not be a concern for career criminals but FOSS tries to stay on the side of the law. Otherwise, projects risk being "tainted" by copy-pasted code that could lead to even larger legal repercussions. ReactOS had its development shut down in 2006 because of mere allegations; they had to prove all their code was written by themselves
https://reactos.org/project-news/reset-reboot-restart-legal-...
But perhaps for contrast we should compare to the other end of the spectrum... Intel uses Minix3 in intelME which is part of every modern intel CPU [0]. Minix3 has a 3 clause BSD license which requires reproducing the copyright notice for basic attribution [1]. Which they failed to reproduce. Now in Tanenbaum's public letter, he politely suggested it would have been courteous if they had merely informed him of what it was being used for [2]... no mention of lack of attribution, no hysteria, no invoking of the mob on twitter, he didn't make even 1/10th the fuss this NPM package developer made.
Lets cut to the chase: The difference between these two people is that one cares about attribution way more than contributing to FOSS. They care about it to such a degree that makes me uncomfortable to touch their code, in-case of any perceived injustice against them or missed opportunity for self-promotion.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intel_Management_Engine#Hardwa...
[1] https://github.com/minix3/minix/blob/master/LICENSE
[2] https://www.cs.vu.nl/~ast/intel/