News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A notable JavaScript developer shamelessly copied one of ... by gopiandcode on Sunday September 26, 2021 @08:01AM (#28660173)
I think it's likely indicative of the fact that the JS ecosystem doesn't really understand the meaning of open source (or the distinction between "open source" and free/libre software).

The author's comments are quite enlightening of their incomplete understanding of the licenses they use:

> nanocolors implementation and API are the same as

> Colorette. You essentially pirated my work.

After using a license that explicitly allows others to take their work, it's suprising the author thinks that someone "pirated" their work.

Hopefully this signals the start of an awakening within the JS ecosystem, with more and more developers switching to licenses like the GPL that actually respect the developers.

Re:A notable JavaScript developer shamelessly copied one of ... by shakna on Sunday September 26, 2021 @09:04AM (#28660558)
> After using a license that explicitly allows others to take their work, it's suprising the author thinks that someone "pirated" their work.

He stripped the license when he created his fork. (Only adding it after the thread on Twitter became actively noticed).

How is that _not_ pirating?

Re:A notable JavaScript developer shamelessly copied one of ... by andix on Sunday September 26, 2021 @08:30AM (#28660370)
For libraries it is very difficult to chose a permissive license. Most companies have a whitelist for licenses for libraries they are allowed to use. And for a good reason. This is mostly MIT, BSD and Apache.

If you use a gpl licensed library in your project, it essentially becomes gpl licensed too. If you ever want to sell your software, this is probably a big no-no. It will become quite challenging, and could end up in a legal desaster.

So to create a successful library, other people are willing to use, you essentially have to release it without restrictions.

Re:A notable JavaScript developer shamelessly copied one of ... by PeterisP on Sunday September 26, 2021 @09:53AM (#28660904)
What about LGPL which is quite explicitly designed for libraries?
Re:A notable JavaScript developer shamelessly copied one of ... by 5560675260 on Monday September 27, 2021 @07:31AM (#28669431)
This could work, but it's just annoying. You'd have to modify your build process to serve this library separately instead of including it in your main bundle and then doing some code splitting.
Re:A notable JavaScript developer shamelessly copied one of ... by afiori on Sunday September 26, 2021 @09:11AM (#28660599)
the work being pirated is not the code but its place in the library marketplace, the license played a minimal role here (as it was infringed anyway)
Re:A notable JavaScript developer shamelessly copied one of ... by detaro on Sunday September 26, 2021 @08:27AM (#28660342)
What exactly would be different here if the project was under GPL?