News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by Justin_K on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:18AM (#28658804)
This is exactly what gun rights advocates have been saying would come, should owners have to register with the state. All this is going to do is punish and put law abiding citizens at risk. I'm sure politicians will be exempt from having their data shared.
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by roenxi on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:36AM (#28658871)
Hypothetically speaking, say we just assumed that basically everything the gun rights advocates are predicting is going to come to pass. Does it matter?

I'm making a guess here that the gun control advocates come in 2 flavours:

1) People who are scared of being shot, and prioritise that fear highly.

2) People who are committed to maintaining the status quo, and don't want there to be even a hypothetical potential for meaningful opposition to the police (such people, though relatively rare, are common in government).

I doubt either of those groups cares about the arguments being made by gun advocates, so I'm not sure what difference it would make if the gun advocates were right about everything.

Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by jacobolus on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:57AM (#28658974)
Group 3: People who don’t want to live in a society where violent thugs use murder or threats of murder to impose their will upon their neighbors, and are tired of seeing their compatriots die easily preventable deaths, in numbers vastly exceeding any other developed country.
[dead]
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by roenxi on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:55AM (#28658962)
Fair enough. So say hypothetically speaking, say we just assumed that basically everything the gun rights advocates are predicting is going to come to pass. Why does it matter?
[dead]
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by roenxi on Sunday September 26, 2021 @03:14AM (#28659028)
That is why I've included a question mark.

Labouring the point a little bit, the initial post wasn't an argument. It was an (admittedly awkward) longform question with a basic intent of "this is what I'm thinking, it doesn't seem very well thought out, where are the soft spots?". Telling me I'm not intelligent doesn't really give me a lead on what to do next.

Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by subhro on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:21AM (#28658816)
Genuinely curious, what do you contemplate/would law abiding citizens be punished for and what is the risk?
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by lambdasquirrel on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:33AM (#28658856)
Gun ownership can be politicized. Let’s not be naive. You would not want to be a known gun owner in some social circles of Alameda County, just as much as you wouldn’t want it to be publicly known that you are LGBTQ+ in Calaveras County.

Privacy is an important right for good reasons.

I don’t own a gun and tend to dislike them. But I work with perfectly fine, sane and normal people who do own guns, and shouldn’t have to be subjected to the judgments of the crowds, just as much as I’ve worked with perfectly fine, sane and normal LGBTQ+ who shouldn’t be subject to the judgments of the crowds.

Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by loeg on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:50AM (#28658940)
It seems like you're trying to draw an equivalence between being LGBTQ and choosing to own guns?
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by irl_chad on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:55AM (#28658961)
Yes he is, and it seems like you’re upset by that.

But his comparison in the context of the fundamental human right to privacy is valid. You have a right to not publish a list of what you own, and you also have a right to not publicly declare your sexuality.

Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by ErrantOctant on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:56AM (#28658968)
Gun ownership is a choice whereas sexuality and gender identity generally are not. I agree that privacy is important and that there are sensible gun owners out there but this is a poor way to frame the argument.
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by akvadrako on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:03AM (#28659205)
Are you saying if somebody who is naturally gay chooses to have straight sex it's then okay to publish a list indicating their sexuality?

Sex acts being a choice or not is irrelevant.

Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by chroem- on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:26AM (#28658832)
We are witnessing the circulation of mass shame lists designed to deprive people of their livelihood. Whether or not you agree that the people on these lists deserve to be hurt for their political opinions, many innocent people are also being caught in the crossfire. This legislation will have a similar effect.
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by Shacklz on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:35AM (#28658869)
> Whether or not you agree that the people on these lists deserve to be hurt for their political opinions, many innocent people are also being caught in the crossfire.

Not sure if your choice of words is very unfortunate or if there's a sarcastic undertone; because in the US there seem to be way too many innocent people that are caught in the literal crossfire of gun violence. Finding ways to address this with legislation seems, from my non-American point of view, only reasonable - and yes, of course it will also affect and limit people that did not contribute to gun violence; what would your solution be, enforcing it only for people who already committed a crime, so essentially when it's too late to inconvenience them?

Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:42AM (#28658901)
Some people hold opinions on pre-crime approach to crime. Some would even argue that creating lists of potential troublemakers, dissidents, and all around problematic characters is.. not noted for great results throughout history.. including that of US. I personally hold this really controversial opinion that crime should be addressed when crime is committed. Doing it before it is committed breaks the fabric of reality and/or common sense.
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by 8note on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:51AM (#28658945)
The US still has said lists(eg. No fly list and sexual offenders lisssst); are you just more okay with having some people on a precrime list than others?
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by isoskeles on Sunday September 26, 2021 @03:27AM (#28659079)
I can't speak for the person you're replying to, but I'm against any No Fly lists, both for the pre-crime aspect and for the the opaqueness with which its implemented.

Sex offenders, by definition, have committed a crime. So that's not really a pre-crime list. Although, sure, some people may not belong on those lists, and it's pretty life-ruining for them.

Your point reads a bit like this: "These injustices exist that you should be against, so why are you supportive of them?"

Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Sunday September 26, 2021 @11:14AM (#28661495)
And I am really uncomfortable with those as well. I am not sure why you would assume I accept those lists and not others for some reason.

No fly list in particular is an abomination. That said, given that Delta is creating a its own version ( and asking other cartel members to join ), soon we may be revisiting this conversation.

Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by Shacklz on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:55AM (#28658965)
The amount of crimes committed with firearms seems to generally correlate with the ease of access to firearms. Trying to make it less convenient to obtain and own firearms, and this includes registration thereof, generally reduces the amount of firearms in circulation, implicitly also reducing the amount of crimes committed with them.

It's like seatbelt-laws, yes, they infringe your personal liberty to do however you pleases, but they also generally help to reduce accidents and, implicitly, reduce cost for society (and not just in terms of money).

Again; from my outsider-point-of-view, that the US even has to have these kinds of discussions seems so weird to me. There are way too many people dying in the US because of the absurd amount of guns, not trying to address this with legislation (as every other advanced nation managed to do) seems outright absurd.

Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by chroem- on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:42AM (#28658900)
The vast majority of firearms that are used in crimes are obtained illegally, and thus will not be subject to these lists. The data on this is widely available. This legislation is purely a punitive political measure.
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by loeg on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:51AM (#28658944)
Illegal guns are former legal guns. S&W doesn't run a factory that only sells to criminals -- those legal guns are diverted to criminals, via the generally lax attitudes of American gun owners.
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by jacobolus on Sunday September 26, 2021 @03:03AM (#28658993)
Indeed. If every gun were registered, and the gun owner (or gun store, or gun manufacturer, whoever last had the registration) faced personal financial/criminal liability when one of their registered guns was used improperly, it would make people take their guns a lot more seriously.
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by LinuxBender on Sunday September 26, 2021 @09:23AM (#28660683)
This is already a thing. I had a rifle stolen some time ago. Shortly thereafter shootings occurred on a freeway nearby with a rifle with the exact caliber as mine. The ATF and DEA were at my house for a chat. Luckily for me, the person that stole my rifle was caught and imprisoned and forensics verified that my firearm did not match the one used in the shooting. I was also lucky I saved the docket number from the Sheriff when I reported it stolen.

I have since left California and moved to a state where everyone is heavily armed. Now my rifles are pea-shooters in comparison to what everyone else around me has. Firearm crime is a very rare occurrence here.

Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by sgc on Sunday September 26, 2021 @11:03AM (#28661406)
If you are attempting to say that stricter guns laws lead to more firearm deaths, you would be quite wrong. California has one of the lowest rates per capita in the US. This law needs some improvements for sure, but here are the CDC stats for the lowest 10 states (columns are deaths, population, and rate per 100k):

  Delaware (10) 93 973,764 9.6
  Iowa (19) 294 3,155,070 9.3
  Minnesota (27) 465 5,639,632 8.2
  California (06) 2,945 39,512,223 7.5
  Connecticut (09) 190 3,565,287 5.3
  Rhode Island (44) 48 1,059,361 4.5
  Hawaii (15) 62 1,415,872 4.4
  New Jersey (34) 368 8,882,190 4.1
  New York (36) 804 19,453,561 4.1
  Massachusetts (25) 247 6,892,503 3.6
From http://wonder.cdc.gov/ucd-icd10.html
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by LinuxBender on Sunday September 26, 2021 @12:33PM (#28662252)
I don't count suicides. My state has a high alcohol consumption rate and high suicide rate (loneliness).

Including only homicide, california is 3.19 per 100k and my state is 2.51 per 100k. Sadly I can't get it to drill down to my county. They also do not include justifiable homicide as a data point.

Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by sgc on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:11PM (#28664217)
Everybody else counts suicides. Also, not knowing your state I am willing bet there are confounding factors. The vast majority of firearm homicides are in urban areas.

I am not going to be able to get the exact same figure as you since the way the search form is set up it is pretty easy to get slightly different numbers. But the only state from the last 3 years of data that would seem to fit your comment is Minnesota. Obviously if you move away from some of the largest metropolitan areas in the US crime rate goes down. But that does not even matter. California still falls in the bottom 8 states despite having several large, difficult metro areas, and the highest percentage of its population living in urban areas of any state, at 95%. In contrast, Minnesota is at 17th, with 73.3%.

Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by chroem- on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:59AM (#28658977)
And there will certainly be a great influx of illegal guns once you provide thieves with a state-compiled shopping list of where to find them.
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by CompanionCubee on Sunday September 26, 2021 @08:40PM (#28665933)
But that will only justify more gun control measures. It's a win-win for them.
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by DisjointedHunt on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:53AM (#28658954)
Precisely. Can't wait for employers to include this in their background checks and deny employment if you own a gun.

I was going to write a statement saying "I hope they sue and the state of CA is held liable for damages" but then the gravity of that sentence hit me. Why do private citizens wanting to simply enjoy a constitutional right have to go to such lengths to do so?

What even if they win the suit? The information is out there legally right now and any one who wishes to use that information to target or harass law abiding citizens is going to be free to do so.

Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by isoskeles on Sunday September 26, 2021 @03:33AM (#28659097)
I can already picture some public health official explaining to CNN viewership that denying employment because of gun ownership is "technically legal because gun owners are not a protected class." Further, I can picture the countless numbers of individuals repeating that factoid on Twitter and in real life like it's some cheatcode to winning the argument.
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by A4ET8a8uTh0 on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:27AM (#28658837)
The risk is always the same. Regular people who happen to own guns will eventually have access to that property removed. Actual criminals won't care, because they don't follow the law. It is an old dance, but it placates specific demographic, who is more scared of a tool than of government power.
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by harlanji on Sunday September 26, 2021 @02:46AM (#28658918)
If an extra-governmental criminal were to get access to the data and wanted to go steal some specific property they would have an efficient seed dataset to be combined with for example MyLife data which lists addresses and family members given a name to go on holiday with.
Re:New CA law allows to pull identifying info of gun owners ... by bitcuration on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:31AM (#28659315)
I believe it's documented already in <<mein kampf>> and the nuremberg trials.

Why human lose memory after merely two generations every single time in the history?