News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Leaked grant proposal details high-risk coronavirus research by bunnie on Saturday September 25, 2021 @09:28AM (#28653012)
Maybe it's the other way around. They put the lab in Wuhan because it's easy to get many samples of the zoonotic viruses of concern due to the presence of many natural reservoirs and wet markets, and you want a lab near the action because you want to be able to study the hot spots.

In other words, your argument is like saying occam's razor concludes that fire extinguishers start fires because they are always found in the vicinity of fires.

Also I think many on this thread greatly underestimate the adaptive and evolutionary capabilities of nature. Having done some wet lab myself, I'm impressed at the ability of nature to do lateral gene transfer, and also it's damn hard to make any experiments work. Plus there are multiple layers of safety and containment around any lab experiment. Movies make engineering look like AI robots in labs and biology experiments that work on the first try, and people who say lab near outbreak must implicate the lab have probably spent more time watching movies about outbreaks than trying to engineer organisms themselves. Having spent a lot of time trying and failing to engineer organisms, occam's razor screams to me that the most likely explanation is natural evolution.

The real lab of concern are the hundreds of millions of people living in close contact with animal reservoirs, performing millions of competitive, uncontrolled evolution experiments daily, with single hosts sometimes simultaneously infected by multiple viruses, thus facilitating lateral gene transfer... and this continues to be the status quo. If you can accept that MERS and SARS CoV-1 are naturally evolved, then occam's razor would indicate that SARS CoV-2 is just one point in a series, and yet another coronavirus outbreak is likely to emerge in the next decade or so, from a dense urban area near animal reservoirs.

Distracting ourselves by fantasizing that only humans could be so devious to create such a virus makes us miss a very important opportunity to try and prevent the next outbreak through careful monitoring and research.

So, if you believe that we should have fire departments and fire extinguishers near ignition sources then, maybe we should have /more/ labs like Wuhan's in high risk areas, not less. And we'd want to encourage more cross border cooperation, not antagonize it, because viruses don't give a damn about your politics.

It's concerning that threads like this, on a forum as ostensibly pro-science as HN, are pushing ourselves further away from science and transparency...

Re:Leaked grant proposal details high-risk coronavirus research by flavius29663 on Saturday September 25, 2021 @09:58AM (#28653261)
> the presence of many natural reservoirs and wet markets, and you want a lab near the action because you want to be able to study the hot spots.

The closest relative to this virus (it's not even that close, just 95% similarity) was found in a bat cave hundreds of miles away. They flew it in Wuhan and made experiments on it (this is all documented, not some crazy theory). Something tells me it's more likely to escape from the lab right there, rather than somehow infect people for hundreds of miles undetected. Your analogy is wrong, the lab is not really a fire extinguisher, because a fire extinguisher cannot cause fires on it's own! Lab leaks happen all the time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_laboratory_biosecurity...

A better analogy is: a nuclear scientist works with heavy metals at a lab (far away from home), suddenly his family gets radiation poisoning. I wonder if it was the scientist that made a mistake, or should we focus all our search for natural radiation sources in the family's house? Sure, it's always a possibility, but what is it more likely? Also, you should at least acknowledge that the person is working with radiation and investigate that possibility thoroughly.

Those lab safety measure were criticized by the US state department https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/04/14/state-dep...

> And we'd want to encourage more cross border cooperation, not antagonize it, because viruses don't give a damn about your politics.

The Chinese took the virus database offline 2 months before the official outbreak...what a coincidence. And what a cooperation effort. Renaming the closest relative virus to hide it's trail. And a lot more.

Yeah, we need more cooperation, and China needs to do it first. They created this mess, the least they can do is cooperate rather than hinder investigations. We need better lab security and better protocols worldwide.

[dead]
Re:Leaked grant proposal details high-risk coronavirus research by avianlyric on Saturday September 25, 2021 @10:22AM (#28653430)
The goal should be to find the truth. Not “hold China accountable”. We can’t punish people for crimes we can’t prove they committed.
Re:Leaked grant proposal details high-risk coronavirus research by sumedh on Saturday September 25, 2021 @09:08PM (#28657519)
> The goal should be to find the truth. Not “hold China accountable”

In this case it is the same thing unless you are claiming Covid started in some other country and they tried to hide the evidence.

Re:Leaked grant proposal details high-risk coronavirus research by avianlyric on Sunday September 26, 2021 @06:25AM (#28659759)
China hasn’t tried to hide the evidence that COVID stated there. But to “hold China accountable” implicitly makes the assumption that they did something wrong and should be punished.

There’s a number of perfectly reasonable ways for COVID to start without China doing anything, and making accusations based on thin evidence is not going to encourage collaboration.

[dead]
Re:Leaked grant proposal details high-risk coronavirus research by avianlyric on Sunday September 26, 2021 @09:13AM (#28660603)
> I dont understand why you keep saying there is thin evidence, we know Covid started in China

I’ve not said that. My comment is in relation to idea that COVID was released from a lab.

> They literally murdered hundreds of thousands of innocent people and yet you still defend a dictatorial regime?

I’m not interested in defending the CCP, I just take offence at the idea of the search for the origin of COVID being a witch hunt. People seem to be much more interested in vilified China, and than they are in the actual origin of COVID.

If you wanna criticise the Chinese government, then be my guest, I won’t defend them. But if you’re going to allow a dislike of China to cloud our understanding of where COVID came from then I’m going to make an objection.

We should focus on evidencing the origin of COVID, not finding reasons to further demonise China. If China have intentionally made it difficult to do that, then criticise the action, but it doesn’t change the fact we don’t have strong evidence of a lab release. Certainly the evidence is currently stronger than the evidence suggesting a natural jump.

Re:Leaked grant proposal details high-risk coronavirus research by sumedh on Sunday September 26, 2021 @10:31AM (#28661167)
> We should focus on evidencing the origin of COVID

Who is we? Is China included as well?

> I just take offence at the idea of the search for the origin of COVID being a witch hunt.

China claims Covid started in the US, where is the evidence for that?

> we don’t have strong evidence of a lab release.

Please read my comments again, I never claimed it leaked from a lab.

Re:Leaked grant proposal details high-risk coronavirus research by avianlyric on Sunday September 26, 2021 @01:11PM (#28662559)
> Please read my comments again, I never claimed it leaked from a lab.

What hell are we talking about then?

> China claims Covid started in the US, where is the evidence for that?

You bought this up not me. I personally don’t give a shit what China claims. I’ve certainly never claimed that COVID originated in US, nor supported the idea. I have no evidence, and have done no research on this claim because I think it’s completely irrelevant, why the hell do you keep putting words in mouth?

> Who is we? Is China included as well?

China can whatever the hell China wants. So no “we” does not include China, I’m only talking about us here on west. Specifically those who seemed to be determined to prove that China is guilty a crime greater than being the unlucky nation where COVID made the jump. Something that’s a naturally occurring event, which is expected to happen on a semi-regular basis. Indeed the lack of new novel virus in the 20th and 21st century is some what notable, especially when you consider how globalised we are as a species.

Re:Leaked grant proposal details high-risk coronavirus research by sumedh on Monday September 27, 2021 @05:13AM (#28668632)
> China can whatever the hell China wants

So China can murder innocent people all over the world, hide or destroy evidence, buy all the PPE from other nations and not be held accountable and you support this, wow, just wow.

> Something that’s a naturally occurring event

Can you give some evidence for this wild claim that Covid was a naturally occurring event.

Re:Leaked grant proposal details high-risk coronavirus research by throwaway210222 on Monday September 27, 2021 @05:24AM (#28668700)
> Can you give some evidence for this wild claim that Covid was a naturally occurring event.

Sure: https://journals.asm.org/doi/pdf/10.1128/JVI.00902-20

Read it (and the referenced documents) until you truly, deeply understand the science well enough to explain it to someone else.

At that point, you will know why the consensus is for natural jump between species.

Oh, and calm down, ranting is unbecoming.

Re:Leaked grant proposal details high-risk coronavirus research by sumedh on Monday September 27, 2021 @10:23PM (#28678599)
Read the link which you gave again but this time see who has funded it. It was funded by the Chinese govt which we have already established that it cannot be trusted.

Dont fall for such state sponsored propaganda and stop making personal attacks using a throwaway account, its very unbecoming.

Re:Leaked grant proposal details high-risk coronavirus research by avianlyric on Friday October 01, 2021 @04:29AM (#28715982)
Read the HN guidelines and stop being an arse.
Re:Leaked grant proposal details high-risk coronavirus research by sumedh on Friday October 01, 2021 @04:35AM (#28716018)
Post some sources for your claim instead of attacking me.