News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by toolz on Friday September 24, 2021 @10:44PM (#28650017)
well over 90% of illicit purchases are done in fiat and you've really not been paying attention if you think those are the only benefits of crypto.

There's an entire country that uses crypto as legal tender. I could stop there, but there's more.

Fees are lower than credit cards charge, there are businesses saving money by utilizing crypto.

Sending money overseas is cheaper and more accessible with crypto.

The list goes on. I'm not sure how you've arrived at your position, but it is not an educated position.

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by shakna on Friday September 24, 2021 @10:52PM (#28650048)
> Sending money overseas is cheaper and more accessible with crypto.

Not in any of the countries that have implemented PayID. (Most of Europe, Aus/NZ, and South America, with the US finally beginning to get on board this year).

It's a case of sending to a mobile phone, with instant-3days timeline, with a cost in 20-50c range for anything less than $10k.

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by toolz on Friday September 24, 2021 @11:00PM (#28650082)
I can send many orders of magnitudes more in crypto (XLM in case you're wanting a reference, but there are more) faster and cheaper than that.

and payID holds first time transactions for 24 hours...this isn't even marginally reasonable for many use-cases

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by shakna on Friday September 24, 2021 @11:04PM (#28650105)
It's not more accessible - and instant (10-30ms) is sort of hard to beat in terms of speed. (Instant is guaranteed for PayID if you have one transaction to that address ever).
Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by toolz on Friday September 24, 2021 @11:12PM (#28650143)
so payID, something not all countries have today can match the speed of crypto, can't match the fees and have a huge block on 1st time transactions.

crypto wins there - payID sounds like it's been something that should've existed decades ago, but crypto has solved this problem and done a better job

and yes it absolutely is more accessible - everywhere except maybe countries that make buying crypto illegal

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by shakna on Friday September 24, 2021 @11:17PM (#28650169)
You can signup to PayID and transfer in the time it takes a waitress to get to your table in around 80% of the known world. How does crypto beat that accessibility? (And it's been around since '02. The US was the last major hold out.)
Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by toolz on Friday September 24, 2021 @11:34PM (#28650261)
payID has KYC just the same as crypto but crypto is globally accessible, cheaper and just as fast

to receive crypto you don't even need KYC actually, just to on-ramp from fiat...and if you mine crypto you don't even need KYC - so again there is no category in which crypto loses and categories where crypto clearly wins

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by shakna on Friday September 24, 2021 @11:39PM (#28650290)
Flat fee of 20c/10k sounds cheaper than crypto to me.

No on-ramp, because payID works for any fiat account that can be linked to Mastercard or Visa sounds more accessible to me.

No specific KYC as its backed by existing banking infrastructure.

I do not see how crypto possibly wins this one.

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by easrng on Friday September 24, 2021 @11:50PM (#28650343)
You can locate, download, install, and set up a crypto wallet and be ready to accept payments in under 2 minutes. (I just did.) Setting up a bank account is far more involved.
Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by perl4ever on Saturday September 25, 2021 @01:32AM (#28650767)
>You can locate, download, install, and set up a crypto wallet

I was under the impression you had to download the blockchain for e.g. bitcoin before you could engage in transactions. Which is something like 350 GB at this point. And then do some processing that takes a while.

Surely this takes a lot more than two minutes.

If you didn't do that, do you really have a crypto wallet?

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by toolz on Saturday September 25, 2021 @12:11PM (#28654218)
you don't have to be a synced, full node to have a wallet that you alone have full control over

So to answer your question, yes I actually own the wallet and no it didn't take more than a minute at most for many different coins

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by perl4ever on Sunday September 26, 2021 @11:59PM (#28666959)
If you're not a "full node" then you have to trust them, don't you? The whole trustless thing goes out the window.

So I'm not sure about that "full control" thing.

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by toolz on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @11:40AM (#28684100)
no, you don't have to be a full node to have complete control of your wallet because of asymmetric cryptography. You hold the private key to your wallet and without that private key no one can spend your funds.

It's not terribly different than if you were to encrypt some file and put it out on the cloud and delete it locally - as long as you have access to the cloud, you are the only one who can make sense of that file with your decryption key.

The distributed network of the blockchain is what ensures you'll have access to a node because most crypto coins have very distributed nodes.

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by perl4ever on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @11:20PM (#28689946)
But which chain? From what I read, it's very important to distinguish between the true chain which full nodes can come to consensus on based on proof of work, and a possible attacker chain which is longer, but low effort.

https://cryptoservices.github.io/blockchain/consensus/2019/0...

And I believe I've read that, when you aren't running a full node, you have to just assume the longest chain is the right one. I mean, all that data is the chain, right? If you don't process it, you have to assume other nodes are trustworthy.

What you are saying about complete control sounds to me like if I said I have complete control over my bank account, in the sense nobody can guess my password, but maybe the bank is fake and I'm not even trying to check.

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by shakna on Saturday September 25, 2021 @12:02AM (#28650415)
But most people _already_ have a bank account. Which means they don't have to set up to use payID. They already can.
Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by toolz on Friday September 24, 2021 @11:44PM (#28650315)
You need to research lightening network for bitcoin if you think that sounds cheaper. I'm sorry, but that's just easily not the case.

80% of the world is not more accessible when the alternative is practically 100% of the world.

also there's no on or off ramp for crypto when you can use it as currency, which is the direction the world is headed.

edit: I'm googling and apparently payID isn't even international. This isn't really even a comparison. I don't know why you believe otherwise.

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by shakna on Saturday September 25, 2021 @12:01AM (#28650406)
> You need to research lightening network for bitcoin if you think that sounds cheaper. I'm sorry, but that's just easily not the case.

Any in-network payID transaction is 0-fees. Whilst lightning does occasionally have negative fees, the fluctuation of Bitcoin means that the fees aren't cheaper in the end.

> 80% of the world is not more accessible when the alternative is practically 100% of the world.

Anywhere with a relationship with Mastercard or Visa is more accessible to most people _today_. Because they absolutely would have to generate or convert fiat to end up with Bitcoin, but have to do absolutely nothing to make use of payID.

You can come back and use that argument if Bitcoin turns around and becomes the defacto currency, but otherwise it falls short. Most people today, have to do nothing to use payID. They have to do something, to use Bitcoin.

> edit: I'm googling and apparently payID isn't even international. This isn't really even a comparison. I don't know why you believe otherwise.

Because it's a set of banking protocols that are international. [0][1][2][3][4][5]

[0] https://www.ecb.europa.eu/paym/integration/retail/instant_pa...

[1] https://www.europeanpaymentscouncil.eu/what-we-do/sepa-insta...

[2] https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2020/08/31/fednow-the-federa...

[3] https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-02-13/new-payments-platform...

[4] https://rg.ru/2019/01/28/v-rossii-zapustili-sistemu-bystryh-...

[5] http://www.npci.org.in/what-we-do/upi/product-overview

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by tyre on Saturday September 25, 2021 @12:38AM (#28650584)
> There's an entire country that uses crypto as legal tender.

El Salvador is a case in point of why crypto is a terrible currency. The first day that they went live, Bitcoin dropped 10%.

> Sending money overseas is cheaper

Right now it's about $2.50 per transaction which is not the cheapest option. Earlier this year we saw transactions fees for BTC hit like $60. Add to that the risk of it dropping 10% in a not-uncommon event…that's not good.

Let's talk about businesses.

First, cost. Let's say you have Stripe's base fee: 30¢ per transaction + 2.9%. For that $2.50 transaction to be cheaper, your purchase would have to be over $75. Is that typical for most businesses? No. And again, that $2.50 is what it is now. It could be $3 in a minute or $20 tomorrow. No one knows.

You think small business owners want that kind of uncertainty? Taking a (???) cut from every monthly SaaS charge does not make sense—not to mention that as you scale Stripe will negotiate prices downwards while BTC will not.

Let's turn to scalability.

BTC clocks in at seven transactions per second. Seven. Transactions can take 10 minutes or longer to process. Imagine a supermarket checkout line where each person blocks for 10 minutes. Or a gas station, subway, restaurant, corner store, coffee shop, or anything else.

Note that I said widespread uses. I am aware that some places are experimenting with bitcoin. I am also aware that crypto has shown to be woefully inadequate for all but a few narrow use-cases.

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by toolz on Saturday September 25, 2021 @10:32AM (#28653483)
This is incredibly uneducated. If I were to talk about fiat with this level of ignorance I would say things like "transferring money takes weeks!" in reference to ACH. Any cursory google search will show you that you are wrong about fees, max tx per second and tx time to finality.

As for bitcoins value, in 12 years it is valued high enough to be in the top 10 market cap stocks.

It took apple 71 years to hit 1T market cap - it took bitcoin 12 years.

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by Sebb767 on Friday September 24, 2021 @10:58PM (#28650073)
> Fees are lower than credit cards charge, there are businesses saving money by utilizing crypto.

That's news to me. Is this true for any of the major coins or just for some obscure one?

Re:I Am Not Satoshi Nakamoto by toolz on Friday September 24, 2021 @11:01PM (#28650088)
lightening network for bitcoin (and many many many other coins/layer2 solutions) are practically free whereas credit cards charge sellers something like 2% _minimum_ on charges.