I always wonder why the only 'financial geniuses' that are landlords are, to a person, such bad landlords.
It wouldn't surprise me at all that a mortgage, after accounting for all factors, is still cheaper than renting.
I mean, there's lots of small restaurant businesses out there, but they don't necessarily generate a real profit or make real financial sense. Some industries just attract irrational or unsophisticated people!
Yeah, he made a 7% return on the real estate itself. BUT, he was also collecting rent on the house the 10 years you were living there. That's a lot more than what he would have gotten from the S&P.
I previously worked in a commercial real estate brokerage for apartment buildings, got to know a lot of landlords, and saw the finances of their properties personally. Over a long enough time span, 90+% of the building has to be replaced- everything from the roof down to the basement is essentially on a clock to obsolence from the moment you sign the deed.
Plus the landlord was paying income tax on the rent while your market gains are untaxed till you sell, etc.
No one gets into these things to lose money. If they start to lose money, they fix up the property and hope for a good market, I would think.
From my experience at a commercial real estate brokerage, forming a personal relationship with dozens & dozens of landlords- it's an extremely unprofessional small business, attracted by people who think 'land, they're not making any more of it' is a sophisticated statement. It also attracts a lot of 'more money than sense' types who are willing to eat losses for the first 5+ years because they think they'll make more money over time. I would conservatively estimate 20-33% of new landlords are actually losing money every year. Could be way higher than that!
Imagine saying 'there's tons of day traders, no one gets into day trading to lose money, so they must all be making $'. In fact, no- it just attracts a lot of unsophisticated folks. Same thing with owning a small retail business or a restaurant- there's lots of restaurants, they're also terrible businesses! I would put being a small landlord closer to owning a restaurant
Being a landlord has costs, but I'm not sure what your point is. Renting property is clearly profitable, or it wouldn't be so common.
A lot of the expenses happen when you switch tenants. In between tenants, before the new tenant arrive, the carpet may have to be replaced, the house may have to be repainted, various other maintenance jobs that are deffered must happen.
That being said, I just spent 10 years renting the same house. My rent did not go up during that time, and my landlord had fairly average maintenance costs during that time including: * replaced broken fridge * paid to have dangerous trees removed * paid to upgrade flooring after a sewer backup flooded the house. Most of this cost was borne by insurance.
My former landlord is now selling the house. The market value of the house is double what it was when I moved in. That sounds awesome, but that's about a 7% rate of return, which is quite a bit less than if he had simply put his money in an S&P 500 index fund.