A youth teen would probably disagree with you regarding their comfortability exposing personal information on the web.
A benefit of BreakkUp is that we're not trying to be a social 'networking' site, it's mostly geared for individuals to use with relative anonymity.
Also, check out http://www.divorce360.com . It seems to be doing pretty well. Maybe you could modify the site to be more of a portal than just a community.
You could add some content to the site (theres lots of information about this topic). Get articles like this:
http://www.wikihow.com/Break-Up
Because of the domain name, you could get a nice rank on search engines.
I think the UI design of the site is great, but the social design needs a lot of work. Breakups are quite personal and messy -- it seems like the last thing people would want to do is expose details on a public forum.