News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Beyond space-time: Welcome to phase space by goodside on Monday August 08, 2011 @12:18PM (#2860572)
I've gotten in the habit of trying to explain poorly written NewScientist and Popular Science articles as they appear on HN, just because they're so consistently peppered with nonsense that even non-physicist enthusiasts like me can do substantially better. But, in this case, I just want to say this:

If you can't close your eyes right now and give me a formal definition of a tensor, you really don't want to waste your time on this. Go buy a good undergrad textbook for $2 used on Amazon. Do the practice problems. It will contain information that will genuinely enlighten you. You will learn things that geniuses of a hundred years ago would have chewed off their own legs just to have hints about. Until you do that, worrying about Lee Smolin will do nothing. At best.

Re:Beyond space-time: Welcome to phase space by hugh3 on Monday August 08, 2011 @12:35PM (#2860627)
Reading things like this is like playing Chinese whispers ("Telephone" in US-ish).

As opposed to the usual situation where the writer knows what the article is about and is struggling to explain it to the audience, in the average New Scientist article we have a situation where the writer doesn't really grasp what the article is supposed to be about either, but has a deadline and a certain amount of space to fill. So you'll see detailed explanations of the bits that the writer did manage to understand combined with quick handwaving and quote-insertion for the bits the writer didn't manage to understand.

The net result is something that contains all the right words and sounds sufficiently clever for laymen, but doesn't make much actual sense. Still, it fills in pages and sells magazines, so it's good enough!

Re:Beyond space-time: Welcome to phase space by lobo_tuerto on Monday August 08, 2011 @12:36PM (#2860632)
I'm a total physics newbie, what book(s) would you recommend picking up?
Re:Beyond space-time: Welcome to phase space by bermanoid on Monday August 08, 2011 @01:00PM (#2860708)
If you're up for a real wild ride and have some time to kill (no, seriously - the thing is over 1000 pages), Roger Penrose's The Road To Reality (http://www.amazon.com/Road-Reality-Complete-Guide-Universe/d...) actually covers this stuff in a reasonably accessible way.

I can't say how it would read to a newbie, but ostensibly he wrote that book to be aimed more at the smart but uninitiated pop-sci audience than the practicing physicists. I'm not sure he hit his mark, quite, but when I was a second year physics undergrad I found it pretty easy to get through at least the first half (though I had worked through MTW's Gravitation first, so I wasn't totally new to the material - also an excellent book, if you've got months to spend on it and some more lightweight general relativity books to look at as supplements).

It probably depends, though - when you say "newbie", do you mean "F=MA means nothing to me and I barely passed single variable calculus", or "I got straight A's in vector calculus and excelled at freshman physics through basic quantum mechanics but never took more"? If it's the former, you'll want to grab Feynman's freshman lectures first, they'll get you thinking right about this stuff if you make it through them, and later you can start to worry about stuff like tensor calculus...

Re:Beyond space-time: Welcome to phase space by lobster_johnson on Tuesday August 09, 2011 @12:21PM (#2864577)
Just make sure you get the right The Road to Reality. This one is going to disappoint: http://www.amazon.com/Road-Reality-COMING-JESUS-UNREAL/dp/15....
Re:Beyond space-time: Welcome to phase space by enko on Monday August 08, 2011 @01:55PM (#2860928)
Unless you and bugsbunnyak are in cahoots somehow - unlikely - that's two completely independent recommendations for The Road To Reality within 5 minutes, on HN. That's enough for me. Grabbing it. Thanks.
Re:Beyond space-time: Welcome to phase space by bermanoid on Monday August 08, 2011 @02:53PM (#2861144)
Not in cahoots at all, it really is a very interesting book. One of the most...different, I guess is the word, math/physics books I've read in quite a while.

Be warned, it might not be the best book for beginners, and in all honesty it's more a math book than a physics one, but if you feel at least somewhat math-competent, it's worth a read. At least I enjoyed it a lot.

Re:Beyond space-time: Welcome to phase space by enko on Monday August 08, 2011 @03:46PM (#2861311)
As a professional programmer, I often feel as if I should be more on top of maths than I feel I am. Maybe this book is above my level. Only one way to find out!

http://xkcd.com/435/

Re:Beyond space-time: Welcome to phase space by bugsbunnyak on Monday August 08, 2011 @01:04PM (#2860730)
Complete physics curriculum up to research-level, available here from a Nobelist: http://www.staff.science.uu.nl/~hooft101/theorist.html

Roger Penrose's "Road to Reality" is great for an overview in one not-so-compact book. It's a bit hand-wavy, admittedly. The neophyte problem, and reason we have universities, is that "you don't know what you don't know." Penrose's book and t'Hooft's curriculum get you some part of the way to knowing what you need to know.

One more option is Lev Landau's series. They're dense but fairly readable for graduate-level tracts.

Re:Beyond space-time: Welcome to phase space by hugh3 on Monday August 08, 2011 @12:56PM (#2860688)
The admissions guide to your nearest major university.