And binary thinking? Just because I do one A/B test doesn't mean the matter is settled. The "winner" of the first test can be tested against other options, whether it's right away or 6 months down the road. It goes on and on & hopefully we get closer and closer to "perfect".
What makes you say that? Did you split-test them? (Serious question.)
If someone holds an opinion but doesn't articulate the reasons for holding it, I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt. But if they try to articulate the reasons and the result is emotional and full of fallacies, I start to think that it's just rationalization and the actual reason is something else, perhaps some opaque emotional reaction that they're trying to justify instead of examining it.
That doesn't mean that what they are saying is incorrect, just that they are very bad at explaining it.
Ex: Most people "believe" in seasons, and evolution. But you ever try to get them to explain what makes those things WORK?