News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Terraform is not the golden hammer by nrvn on Sunday September 19, 2021 @02:57PM (#28586901)
One of the biggest reasons that have kept me away from terraform apart from the esoteric language is that terraform modules are always a few steps being from the upstream public cloud offerings.

In the sense that whenever there’s a new API or service available in any of public clouds and their official SDKs there will always be a delay before this new service/feature/API will become available in terraform.

First time I encountered it with GKE private clusters 3 or 4 years ago. Now it is AWS Keyspaces.

The second biggest reason is whenever you have a requirement for a hybrid or multicloud then well you are left with rigidity if HCL. It is probably doable but for what sake?

Solution: get a real language, write a STATELESS configuration management(IaC) system for your own needs and maintain it. The majority of public and private cloud providers ship SDKs in most popular languages that will help you build your own software solution and reduce your dependence on a third party which I would put under progressing operational risk category. Yaml/json/cue/toml for end user configs would suffice.

Example: for one of my previous projects were built a tool for a hybrid AWS-openstack setup, and were managing a dozen of busy environments.

Re:Terraform is not the golden hammer by xyzzy_plugh on Sunday September 19, 2021 @03:04PM (#28586970)
This is my preference as well. I've done everything from makefiles and bash scripts to a monolith Go program that statelessly provisions/tears down resources.

Even makefiles are pretty straightforward, though you really want operations to only trigger when checksums differ -- timestamps result in a lot of redundant operations. As long as everything is idempotent, it's pretty straightforward.

Re:Terraform is not the golden hammer by oceanplexian on Sunday September 19, 2021 @03:24PM (#28587114)
> Terraform modules are always a few steps being from the upstream public cloud offerings.

My experience has been the exact opposite. Usually Terraform offers support for cloud services long before the vendor provides an SDK or supports it with their own offering (e.g. Cloudformation). There are still dozens of AWS services, for example that have no CF support offered by AWS.

Re:Terraform is not the golden hammer by nrvn on Sunday September 19, 2021 @03:01PM (#28586938)
The emphasis on stateless here is that your desired state us described in code that resides in your repository. Actual state is what you have in your cloud. No need to spend time on state format, storage and related logic and complexity
Re:Terraform is not the golden hammer by deimosfr on Monday September 20, 2021 @02:47AM (#28590934)
I mostly agree with this, but you're not considering the time it takes to make and maintain it over time. It is non-negligible and has to be in the balance as well. But from a pure technical POV, I agree.