Re:Ask HN: What is your strongest contrarian opinion?
by HarHarVeryFunny on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:18PM
(#28581393)
> what is dark matter
Dunno. Does it even exist? Is there any inkling of this proposed stuff NOT acting according to some deducible laws. Seems pretty boring stuff - interacts with regular matter just via gravity. Do we have it in our head ? :-)
> is there a theory of quantum gravity
Is that a practical issue for predicting behavior of physical systems at any given scale? I'm pretty sure we don't need quantum gravity to adequately understand the chemistry of our brains.
> what is consciousness
Self-introspection via feedback paths in the brain. Damage those feedback paths and you'll get a condition such as "blind sight" where you can provably see, but not be aware of your ability to see.
> how does the universe exist
Dunno, but we're in it, and governed by how things behave in it. That question seems a bit off-topic regarding free will within our universe!
> is there any kind of fundamental randomness
Dunno. I'd bet not. Does it matter at the level of classical physics and above?
> are two particles of same type actually the same
Not sure what you're referring to. The Pauli exclusion principle?
> how about Godel's incompleteness theorems, etc
What's the relevance to the discussion? I can't prove what the stock market is going to do tomorrow either.
Dunno. Does it even exist? Is there any inkling of this proposed stuff NOT acting according to some deducible laws. Seems pretty boring stuff - interacts with regular matter just via gravity. Do we have it in our head ? :-)
> is there a theory of quantum gravity
Is that a practical issue for predicting behavior of physical systems at any given scale? I'm pretty sure we don't need quantum gravity to adequately understand the chemistry of our brains.
> what is consciousness
Self-introspection via feedback paths in the brain. Damage those feedback paths and you'll get a condition such as "blind sight" where you can provably see, but not be aware of your ability to see.
> how does the universe exist
Dunno, but we're in it, and governed by how things behave in it. That question seems a bit off-topic regarding free will within our universe!
> is there any kind of fundamental randomness
Dunno. I'd bet not. Does it matter at the level of classical physics and above?
> are two particles of same type actually the same
Not sure what you're referring to. The Pauli exclusion principle?
> how about Godel's incompleteness theorems, etc
What's the relevance to the discussion? I can't prove what the stock market is going to do tomorrow either.