Re:Lessons from a Design Legend (a before-and-after)
by CamperBob on Sunday August 07, 2011 @08:10PM
(#2858209)
Gotta agree. I was honestly unsure at first which screenshots were from the "before" design and which were from "after." In the majority of cases the original design was better at delivering both usability and clarity, as you say.
Here's a litmus test for those who like the newer design better: would you want your OS to look like that? Not everything should look like an OS UI, of course, but take a few moments to think about why you wouldn't want your OS and most of your other day-to-day applications to look like the "after" design.
The second design did make some good changes, particularly larger pictures of food, however it comes off as too design heavy and lacking clarity in several areas.
Overall I feel there is more clarity with what you want me to do in the first design.
Edit: You have to view the work as a whole when comparing the designs side by side. There were several important parts of Mike's design that were cut out to fit the blog post that actually bring a ton more clarity.