As a user I quickly get suspicious when there is a lot of style. I quickly pick up the difference between the veneer and the inner wood, so to speak, and as a user, the first thing I look for, perhaps subconsciously, is the way through the veneer. I need to use buttons and fields and read the important stuff, all the way trying to ignore the style -- the baroque embellishments, the clever icons, the careful colour balance -- which is functionally superfluous.
The main problem with style is that it obscures and dimishes the value of information. Good UI design is functional and elegant and avoids stylistic embellishments. The old design was simple and to the point. The new design is very busy and unsimple. It reminds me of the kind of excessively flowery, explosive embellishments typical of indie festival poster designs that was in vogue the last 2-3 years, but has been going out of fashion, like this one: http://bit.ly/nzJaR3. Another problem with style is that it's easy to seem derivative and as though you are trying too hard. Nobody could fault the simple, apparently genuinely sincere ambitions of your old design. Now your design is ambitious in a kind of pompus way, and easier to shoot down.
Yet another problem with style is that it can seem to imply a level of information quality. It's difficult to articulate, but look at the third section of your article, the way restaurants are presented. Instead of the old, close-to-the-database look, we now have something out of a coffee table book. The level of polish seems to imply that the information itself has been carefully harvested, edited, quality-checked and polished. But in your case (I'm presuming), some entries are probably more rougher than others, and the surface polish is not representative of the actual content.
Just my few humble cents.
Simple and to the point designs often lack personality. And if you're trying to build a brand your site design needs to have a point of view.
For example, the minimalistic Japanese "no-brand" (it's very much a brand) MUJI has very little actual style, but lots of design. It's simplistic and function-oriented. And yet the personality is often immediately recognizable. IKEA is often minimalistic, but has a significant brand presence without applying a whole of style.
Style is like makeup. You're not making a cake, so you have to be careful about how much you apply. Too much makeup and you come across as desperate or insincere. Too little and your wrinkles will be showing. I don't know how far one can stretch this metaphor -- you get the point. :-)
1. For us, that's exactly what we wanted. It's Mike Kus' style applied to our product.
2. The mobile app actually looks quite different. If you visit www.giftrocket.com on your phone, it's a functional version of our website. The phone app comparisons were of one specific screen within the redemption flow.
(Iconography is hard. These days kids are probably asking about those weird icons in toolbars that they don't recognize, and moms and dads need to explain how back in the day we used quaint things like floppy disks and clipboards and stuff; soon they will have to explain about envelopes and magnifying glasses. Apple, meanwhile, just moved iCal back a decade by introducing a leather-bound framing metaphor for the entire app.)
OTOH, it is amazing that some designers just repeat the same motifs in every work they do, and make a career out of it. Another one is Michael Schwab. I love his work but it is all very samey: http://www.michaelschwab.com/portfolio_posters.html
1. It's very de auteur. If you watch it in contrast with every other Mike Kus design as beautiful and awesome they are you'll see that this design is not that original and looks just every other Mike Kus design. 2. The mobile app looks like a giant bueautiful useless splash screen. It has a lot more graphics and details and yet it conveys a lot less information that the 'before' design. For starters, that the damn button is clickable and it will redeem something from Mario's Pizzeria.
Or am I just becoming an old cranky designer?