News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Help me kill IMAP and Exchange in a single blow by drdaeman on Sunday August 07, 2011 @02:14PM (#2857292)
> All communication over HTTP / HTTPS

Why HTTP? And, for example, not BEEP? HTTP can't handle multiple concurrent logical streams, thus can provide you with one resource per connection at a time. Every separate HTTP (and HTTPS) connection requires a TCP (and TLS) handshake, re-authentication and so on.

Also, long-polling is a hack, born because of HTTP limitations. Is there any reason to do long-polling when you can just send a signal over bidirectional connection?

This could be a unpopular opinion (lots of web developers out there), but I believe, while it is perfectly possible to use HTTP, it is just plain ugly for such job.

> Stateless

Is wrong for protocols where you require a state (authentication, folder/label subscription and so on). How many stateless pub-sub protocols you know about? Be it lightweight Redis Pub/Sub or XML-bloated AMQP and XMPP - they're all stateful for a reason.

HTTP cookies do represent state. You're just taking a shortcut by re-authentication with a session token. The state you keep could be only auth data (so you'll end up re-sending, for example, what labels you're interested in every time), but it's still a state.

There are no comments on this comment yet.