News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Just the Facts: S&P's $2 Trillion Mistake by orijing on Sunday August 07, 2011 @01:42PM (#2857168)
"We can pay back our debt since it's denominated in dollars" is a meme thrown around online blogs, but it is misguided. If the way the debt is paid back is through currency devaluation, it's safe to say that the investors were not truly paid back--i.e. there was a loss of principal measured in purchasing power.

So while it's true that the US can always pay back the full dollar amount of how much it owes, it's less true that it'll pay back the total "purchasing power" that the bondholder gave up to buy US bonds. Therefore, there's additional risk even if you will get your money back.

However, in that light all dollar-denominated debts should be downgraded for the same reason that US treasury bonds are--for the additional currency risk should the government choose to "default" by devaluation.

Re:Just the Facts: S&P's $2 Trillion Mistake by prostoalex on Sunday August 07, 2011 @05:29PM (#2857791)
Not all US debt is classic Treasuries. They also sell inflation-linked debt instruments, such as TIPS and I-Bonds.
Re:Just the Facts: S&P's $2 Trillion Mistake by JeffL on Monday August 08, 2011 @02:34AM (#2859068)
I forgot who said it recently, but I thought it was a really interesting point that printing money to pay the debt is like partially defaulting.
Re:Just the Facts: S&P's $2 Trillion Mistake by fauigerzigerk on Sunday August 07, 2011 @01:46PM (#2857185)
That's exactly what I said. The keyword is "nominal obligations".
Re:Just the Facts: S&P's $2 Trillion Mistake by orijing on Sunday August 07, 2011 @01:51PM (#2857210)
I was answering "Why is the ability to pay considered at all when it comes to the US?"

Perhaps I misunderstood your comment, but it read like "it doesn't matter because we can pay all debts."

Re:Just the Facts: S&P's $2 Trillion Mistake by fauigerzigerk on Sunday August 07, 2011 @02:00PM (#2857247)
The government can always pay its nominal debt with interest. I didn't say they were not going to inflate the debt away or that this would be OK. But S&P did not make that assumption in its rating. S&P assumes a 2% inflation rate.
Re:Just the Facts: S&P's $2 Trillion Mistake by gojomo on Sunday August 07, 2011 @04:19PM (#2857624)
Whether S&P says it or not, then, we should consider part of the 'default' risk being that USGov intentionally, strategically breaks those stated inflation assumptions.
Re:Just the Facts: S&P's $2 Trillion Mistake by sethg on Monday August 08, 2011 @10:45AM (#2860208)
If there is a risk that the US will significantly inflate the currency, then that risk should be reflected in the ratings for all dollar-denominated bonds, not just Treasuries. But there are still AAA-rated corporate bonds. Heck, S&P still rates the bonds of 13 states as AAA, which makes no sense to me.
Re:Just the Facts: S&P's $2 Trillion Mistake by fauigerzigerk on Sunday August 07, 2011 @04:42PM (#2857670)
Yes, exactly. That's what the bond market does anyway and according to the bond market there is currently no danger of any inflation whatsoever.
Re:Just the Facts: S&P's $2 Trillion Mistake by nandemo on Sunday August 07, 2011 @04:07PM (#2857594)
What is your point?

The meaning of the downgrade is, if the inflation rate is 2% then there's a risk that US doesn't pay its debts. Now, if US does pay the nominal debts as you assume, then you cannot assume the inflation rate is only 2%.

If paying the nominal debt guaranteed an AAA rate regardless of inflation, then every country in the world would have an AAA rate. Argentina would just print a lot of pesos and then buy US dollars with it. Europe would just print a ton of euros and Greece et. al. would have no problems.

Re:Just the Facts: S&P's $2 Trillion Mistake by fauigerzigerk on Sunday August 07, 2011 @04:40PM (#2857669)
If paying the nominal debt guaranteed an AAA rate regardless of inflation, then every country in the world would have an AAA rate

No, because creating peso inflation does not reduce Argentinas dollar debt. But dollar inflation does reduce the USA's dollar debt. Therefore it makes sense to rate the ability of Argentina to pay its nominal dollar denominated debt but it makes no sense at all to rate the ability of the US to pay its dollar denominated debt.