News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

NordVPN Linux does not enforce 2FA even it's enabled in user settings

Security problem: Linux version of the NordVPN client does not enforce 2FA (Two factor authentication) even it is enabled in user settings.

After installation there the Linux NordVPN does not EVER verify the 2FA code. This is what happens:

--- snip ---

memyself@mylinux ~> sudo su

root@mylinux:/home/homeuser# nordvpn status

Status: Disconnected

root@mylinux:/home/homeuser# nordvpn login

Please enter your login details.

Email: [email protected]

Password: *******

Welcome to NordVPN!

You can now connect to VPN by using 'nordvpn connect'.

root@mylinux:/home/homeuser# nordvpn connect France

Connecting to France #742 (fr742.nordvpn.com)

You are connected to France #742 (fr742.nordvpn.com)!

root@mylinux:/home/homeuser#

--- snip ---

That log is from Linux Mint 20.2 with all the latest patches, kernel and latest version of NordVPN Linux (3.10.0) (normal apt upgrade process done for everything). Username, hostname etc. have been just modified for privacy purposes.

Also note note, this happened on the first run on that Linux computer so 2FA should've been enforced. But at in any point does the NordVPN client call for 2FA token. :(

Now, a honest question:

Who does not see this as a potential security hole here? It's the NordVPN server who should ensure that not ANY client can log in without correct 2FA token if it's enabled. Now a Linux client can any time login if correct credentials are known.

It seems that the the 2FA is implemented on the client side completely. Which is not the correct way to do it. Fake spoofing NordVPN clients start to arrive which can bypass 2FA on any account.

Windows and Mobile NordVPN clients seem to enforce it, but if the 2FA verification is done on client side then the whole meaning is nullified.

Btw, this happened when I posted the above msg in r/nordvpn

FeedbackSorry, this post has been removed by the moderators of r/nordvpn.Moderators remove posts from feeds for a variety of reasons, including keeping communities safe, civil, and true to their purpose.

Mopping a serious problem under the carpet?

( 7 comments | 37 points | on HN )
Re:NordVPN Linux does not enforce 2FA even it's enabled in u... by sgjohnson on Friday September 17, 2021 @08:21PM (#28572366)
I don’t actually see an issue as to why would you need a 2FA for NordVPN at all.

I’m also a NordVPN customer, and not only I do not use 2FA, I deliberately use easy to guess, previously compromised passwords. I’ve also handed out those credentials to plenty of my friends.

Just in case they happen to log the network activity of their users, what this can achieve is plausible deniability and noise. Lots of noise.

Re:NordVPN Linux does not enforce 2FA even it's enabled in u... by implying on Friday September 17, 2021 @10:22PM (#28573030)
I agree. Isn't a VPN a usecase where you'd like to authenticate yourself as little as possible?

For comparison, mullvad accounts have no separate identification and authentication. Each account is a 16 digit number, and knowledge of that number allows you to administer the entire account. Usernames and passwords don't exist

Re:NordVPN Linux does not enforce 2FA even it's enabled in u... by vmoore on Saturday September 18, 2021 @12:15PM (#28577287)
> For comparison, mullvad accounts have no separate identification and authentication

Yeah this was a huge learning curve for me. When you use a Mullvad OpenVPN config file, the username is your account number, and the password is the account number too.

All a bad actor has to do is enumerate account numbers programmatically and they could potentially own hundreds of accounts, although generating those would be difficult and a lot of it relies on chance.

Re:NordVPN Linux does not enforce 2FA even it's enabled in u... by Anunayj on Friday September 17, 2021 @08:15PM (#28572317)
If this is a legitimate issue, you should have first tried to contact NordVPN through their official bug bounty program [1] with steps to reproduce and exploit's consequences, given them adequate time to fix it, and then gone public with the vulnerability. (As long as your reward terms allowed you to)

They're probably not mopping the issue under the carpet, but rather reddit is not their bug reporting platform.

Though the page does say account takeover is out of scope, so I'm unsure what the program is even for.

[1] https://hackerone.com/nordsecurity

Re:NordVPN Linux does not enforce 2FA even it's enabled in u... by RL_Quine on Friday September 17, 2021 @08:24PM (#28572379)
At this point I’d disagree; “bug bounty” programs are designed to frustrate reporters, cover up issues, and serve neither the reporter or users of a service. Guilting people fully disclosing isn’t really doing much to improve the situation for anybody.
Re:NordVPN Linux does not enforce 2FA even it's enabled in u... by rileymat2 on Friday September 17, 2021 @10:29PM (#28573080)
The public has no obligation to do free QA for a company. If they are getting people going public and not through the bug bounty program, that is on them for not making the stakes high enough.
Re:NordVPN Linux does not enforce 2FA even it's enabled in u... by ranguna on Saturday September 18, 2021 @04:29AM (#28574601)
Nordvpn on Linux doesn't work at all, period.

The client keeps on failing to request the list of available serves because of some strange networking bug.