News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Surveillance capitalism will transform the domain name sy... by verdverm on Friday September 17, 2021 @01:14PM (#28568025)
They have in fact used phrases like "overthrow" and "collision course"

You have to look at their behavior and communications over time and beyond their website

Some of the community wants to aggressively replace ICANN, that is the context, not changing how DNS works.

https://github.com/handshake-org/hs-names/issues/6#issuecomm...

This is the flaw, being an uncooperative community member in the DNS ecosystem

Re:Surveillance capitalism will transform the domain name sy... by SkyMarshal on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:43PM (#28580968)
The word "overthrow" is not used anywhere in that thread.

"Collision" is used 26 times, mainly referring to name collisions between different root zone domains or to the ICANN NCAP project (Name Collision Analysis Project).

"Collision Course" is used only once, by a contributor who was not part of the original Handshake team but joined and became a major contributor later.

Hardly representative of the entire community, and definitely not of the founding team.

Re:Surveillance capitalism will transform the domain name sy... by evbots on Friday September 17, 2021 @04:18PM (#28570421)
the context for that comment is that handshake took a snapshot of the icann namespace. so any names icann adds or changes after the fact will conflict with the HNS namespace.
Re:Surveillance capitalism will transform the domain name sy... by verdverm on Saturday September 18, 2021 @09:20PM (#28580868)
The comment is the start of a longer thread that is one data point in understanding how HNS would rather be adversarial than cooperative, from my perspective and others. Much of the crypto public speak is about replacing rather than enhancing existing systems. There is no join, only beat. They would likely become the very thing they desire to replace. It's human nature
Re:Surveillance capitalism will transform the domain name sy... by evbots on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:51PM (#28618639)
There are factions within crypto, some think the "end of history" looks like crypto replacing centralized systems. others (like myself) think those systems are complements and simply alternatives in the marketplace.

As to being adversarial... ICANN was allocated 1.2% of the total HNS supply, and all existing TLD owners (at the time of the snapshot) can claim their TLDs on chain. The icann allocation is 5.8% of the current circulating supply.

i suppose there could have been a way to give ICANN a blank check to modify the handshake namespace in perpetuity, but i suspect that might either be technically unworkable or just made the whole venture pointless.