Re:Mark Cuban: If you want to see more jobs created -- chang...
by noonespecial on Sunday August 07, 2011 @10:06AM
(#2856612)
I love this idea. I can't own a house or a car without paying tax on it every year. If they insist that its intellectual "property", then they'd best start treating it like property.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Mark Cuban: If you want to see more jobs created -- chang...
by corin_ on Monday August 08, 2011 @04:18AM
(#2859250)
You don't pay any tax in relation to the fact that a house or a car is property, it's based on (depending where you live) stuff like local services, roads, etc.
If you buy a £50k rolex do you have to pay tax on it every year?
Re:Mark Cuban: If you want to see more jobs created -- chang...
by artsrc on Monday August 08, 2011 @07:50AM
(#2859699)
This very much depends on jurisdiction. Certainly in California more expensive cars, which use the same roads, pay more tax. Similarly with property, where a more expensive property (perhaps with one by the harbour with the view, which has the same amount of garbage etc. pays more property taxes.
Certainly in say Sydney, property tax (goes to state government revenue, only paid by large land owners) and council rates (pays for garbage collection, paid by everyone) are separate.
Re:Mark Cuban: If you want to see more jobs created -- chang...
by corin_ on Monday August 08, 2011 @07:54AM
(#2859713)
Here in the UK council tax is tied directly to the value of the property too - it's not because it needs more services, just an extension of the logic behind income tax, that people who can afford to pay more, pay more.
My point remains that you can't tie a link between "if it is property, it gets taxed".
Re:Mark Cuban: If you want to see more jobs created -- chang...
by beagle3 on Monday August 08, 2011 @11:47AM
(#2860450)
But much like local services, IP needs government services to function -- it's the customs service that stop cheap knockoff imports, it's the legal system that makes others stop using your patent or levy the rent you as a patent/copyright owner seek. (And eventually, it's the police force and prison system that underwrites the legal system's power).
So it's really no different than other "taxes for services" arrangements.
Re:Mark Cuban: If you want to see more jobs created -- chang...
by corin_ on Monday August 08, 2011 @01:40PM
(#2860855)
I wasn't getting into the question of whether IP should be taxed, merely replying to this statement:
If they insist that its intellectual "property", then they'd best start treating it like property.
So regardless of whether IP should be taxed, the argument for taxing it is not that all property is taxed - because it isn't.
Re:Mark Cuban: If you want to see more jobs created -- chang...
by beagle3 on Tuesday August 09, 2011 @11:31AM
(#2864368)
> regardless of whether IP should be taxed, the argument for taxing it is not that all property is taxed - because it isn't.
That's true. But hard-to-hide expensive stuff (houses, cars, land) IS taxed because it is hard-to-hide and expensive, and patents could equally well have the same fate.
Re:Mark Cuban: If you want to see more jobs created -- chang...
by noonespecial on Monday August 08, 2011 @10:03AM
(#2860086)
It would be too hard to track the Rolex. If they could, they would. My business is taxed on all it's assets. Rolexs included.
In theory, they tell you it's services, etc. In practice, they rent-seek everything they can reliably lay eyes on.