Re:Help me kill IMAP and Exchange in a single blow
by Navarr on Sunday August 07, 2011 @05:11AM
(#2856257)
You're absolutely right! Thank you.
I'll need to take extra care to focus on the main issue before extending it.
I just also want the extensibility to be a center focus, so that it can expand to be a synchronization protocol instead of only an email protocol.
Re:Help me kill IMAP and Exchange in a single blow
by karl_nerd on Sunday August 07, 2011 @05:45AM
(#2856312)
Can someone shoot this thing down:
What if we think 'data synchronisation protocol' instead of 'e-mail protocol'?
E-mail would then be an 'append only' application of this. The protocols focus would be to register a piece of data, keep track of the 'owner' and sharers and maintain synchronisation (preferably in a peer-to-peer way). I know this problem is big, but once it's done in a reliable way it would be simple to build a good e-mail-style communication on top of it.
Re:Help me kill IMAP and Exchange in a single blow
by JoachimSchipper on Sunday August 07, 2011 @06:41AM
(#2856372)
UUCP was pretty much this. E-mail was, in fact, built on top of it; at least Sendmail still supports it.
I'm sure you can still find the reasons for the transition to SMTP somewhere. Try, again, Sendmail archives.
Re:Help me kill IMAP and Exchange in a single blow
by derefr on Sunday August 07, 2011 @06:41AM
(#2856373)
You mean... Google Wave?
This by itself makes me believe this is doomed.
Part of the problem with IMAP is that it's incredibly complex. That complexity, and differing interpretations of that complexity, is a huge part of what makes IMAP such a headache to deal with.
Simplicity is a virtue. Don't add everything you can think of, strip out everything you don't absolutely have to have. It's fine if the protocol is extensible, but your first and primary goal should be to have a system that synchronizes email reliably and efficiently. Get that right, then start worrying about the extra stuff. Until then, you're just making life harder.