News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Golang: Code of Conduct Updates by _moof on Thursday September 16, 2021 @06:42PM (#28558734)
I agree that cancelling someone over an accidental transgression is a vengeful overreaction. Separately, let me ask you this: If I step on your foot, does it hurt less if I didn't mean to?
Re:Golang: Code of Conduct Updates by indigochill on Thursday September 16, 2021 @07:24PM (#28559089)
If you say you meant to, I will exclude you from my dancing events to protect the other dancers' feet. If you say you didn't mean to, you know, my foot still hurts but you're still welcome to my dancing events because it probably won't happen again.

My foot hurting actually has no bearing on whether or not you're welcome.

Conversely, if you say it's an accident but somehow you have a conspicuously high foot-stomping incidence among many dance partners, I probably will exclude you because I will stop believing the foot-stomping is accidental (or you're just very unfortunately clumsy, terribly sorry, but I still have to protect the other dancers' feet).

Re:Golang: Code of Conduct Updates by _moof on Friday September 17, 2021 @02:03PM (#28568802)
> My foot hurting actually has no bearing on whether or not you're welcome.

Of course - that was my point about cancelling being an overreaction to accidental transgressions. I think the thing that gets missed is that an accidental transgression still causes harm, and harm warrants the making of amends. "You break it, you buy it" applies whether or not you meant to knock that lamp over. If I step on your foot I apologize. Etc.

Re:Golang: Code of Conduct Updates by indigochill on Friday September 17, 2021 @07:22PM (#28572001)
> and harm warrants the making of amends

Generally, yes, of course. Though once we leave the realm of hypothetical foot-stomping for politics, things can get more complicated.

For example, we might look at the John Cena incident where he "acknowledged Taiwan as a country", which somehow led to him later making an apology video (in Chinese?) for this "offense" against mainland China.

So sometimes accusations of "harm" are merely manipulation. It can take discernment to judge when amends are actually warranted.

Re:Golang: Code of Conduct Updates by type0 on Thursday September 16, 2021 @06:53PM (#28558837)
that depends if you are wearing high heels or not