News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:10 people who don't matter (2006) by SoftwareMaven on Sunday August 07, 2011 @12:20AM (#2855751)
To the average reader of CNN, git is a piece of software they've never heard of, much less understand why it's better. Linus never stopped being important to the software community, but git doesn't make him more important to the non-software community.
Re:10 people who don't matter (2006) by ericd on Sunday August 07, 2011 @12:42AM (#2855782)
I guess that just leaves starting the OS that powers most of the web.
Re:10 people who don't matter (2006) by pbreit on Sunday August 07, 2011 @02:57AM (#2856034)
Github is more important than git so I guess that leaves figuring out how important linus or git was to the origin of github. Is here something about git specifically that made it more suitable for github than say mercurial or bazaar? Or was it timing or happenstance?
Re:10 people who don't matter (2006) by xilun0 on Sunday August 07, 2011 @01:12PM (#2857092)
It's debatable whether github is more important than git or not. Despite the impression a reader of this site could have that (hype and with an user interface copy pasted from the prototype hype fashion simple user interface of the moment, with Big Buttons tm included) hosted services are the best thing since sliced bread and will replace everything, the world is interestingly neither centered around that, and it's indeed very ironic to value importance of centralized services more than the decentralized tool it embraces and extend, given many of the advances in the source code management area and development workflow directly come from the decentralized aspects.

That Hg also exist does not make git less important than github, no more than the fact that sourceforge exists make github less important than git.

Re:10 people who don't matter (2006) by pbreit on Monday August 08, 2011 @02:32PM (#2861067)
While I happen to think the Github UI is quite nice, it's a minor aspect of Gihub's importance. Github basically invented "social coding" which I would argue has been a genuine phenomenon unmatched by BitBucket, Launchpad, et al (or Sourceforge). Git (and Mercurial) didn't offer substantial advancements over Bitkeeper (save licensing) and Git's popularity was solidified with it being chosen for Linux. While reasonable people may disagree on the merits of Git, Hg and Bazaar, it's difficult to put BitBucket and Launchpad in Github's circle.

While it may be ironic to value the importance of centralization on this topic, it's unwise to not to value it.

Downvote? Really?

Re:10 people who don't matter (2006) by xilun0 on Tuesday August 09, 2011 @11:39AM (#2864401)
How would you define "social coding"?