2) How do I know which things need to be certified as inventions? Software patents are so vague that even simple applications can infringe hundreds of them. iOS apps are being sued just for having in-app upgrades.
3) Anything that requires more beurocracy or litigation is only going to make things worse because small players can't even afford to make use of the system, especially when they are fighting against dedicated full-time lawyers. The only alternative to solving that underlying problem is eliminating the ways it can be exploited.
2) Eligible inventions would include anything that a customer pays for - as in the exchange of value designates the scope of invention from a patent enforcement perspective. From a patent defense perspective, as long as the invention logs show no use of another patent (when the attacking inventor requests certification at their own expense). This would also focus invention on creation of value instead of creation of legal IP.
3) I disagree, this proposal is an attempt to let people opt out of a broken system by certifying invention through at least one adopted methodology of original design. Again, think of it like buying insurance - every complex industry requires some sort of overhead to deal with subjective enforcement of laws. The capping of costs reduces the average overhead so much vs the current system where anyone who succeeds in the market pays a big, unpredictable legal tax.
Seriously? Who the fuck has time...
You hear of an existing product? Who cares? If you can invent something similar without referencing related documentation or code during the actual process of invention keep it out of the legal system.
A new kind of certification for complex and novel inventions will not solve anything, because it's the simple and obvious inventions that everyone depends on that expose us to patent attacks.
Our government provides us many freedoms in the constitution, perhaps an amendment is a better proposal. That way the courts can interpret a more meaningful definition of Freedom to Invent as a way of shaping the current patent system.
One could, however, have a system where if two separate teams file patents before either are published, they should not have to license it.
Ideas evolve over time, and the originate from something. Perhaps if inventors were willing to register their invention documents through a set of steps mapping to something like the Technology Readiness Level (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Technology_readiness_level), then they could be eligible for immunity against patent based litigation.
But lets say this certified patent wants to protect its IP on the market through litigation. In this case, the inventor could first request certification of the invention in question before any further legal action occurred.
If we could create a certification process that is less than $2000 or so (about the cost of a provisional patent including attorney fees), it seems feasible. This system would seek to encourage a regulated invention process that filters new inventions from even being eligible for litigation. This allows for inventor insurance in a sense - keeping a capped cost for protecting certifiably original ideas while encouraging original invention and discouraging the incentive behind patent lawsuits.