News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:10 people who don't matter (2006) by InclinedPlane on Saturday August 06, 2011 @11:41PM (#2855676)
They don't, not statistically anyway. Some people still listen to them because of confirmation bias, failure to understand statistics, and because there generally isn't a strong incentive for anyone to fact check such predictions after the fact.

Given that in this case out of a list of 10 there were 3 very devastatingly bad predictions I think that's pretty damning. More so when you consider that it's rare for a company to matter, so picking 10 big CEOs that don't matter should be highly biased toward correct predictions.

Re:10 people who don't matter (2006) by krakensden on Sunday August 07, 2011 @03:08AM (#2856060)
> More so when you consider that it's rare for a company to matter, so picking 10 big CEOs that don't matter should be highly biased toward correct predictions.

You've got it backwards. His pool for picks isn't the set of all CEOs, it's the set of all CEOs who are well known, have mattered recently, and are still working. That's a very different pool, with a very different bias.

Re:10 people who don't matter (2006) by InclinedPlane on Sunday August 07, 2011 @04:27AM (#2856186)
Fair enough. But without a good comparison against random picks from the same pool it's impossible to judge the quality of these picks. Given that there were a few gimmes in the list (slashdot and vonage for example), and given the notable absence of plenty of high profile CEOs in 2006 who foundered shortly after I'm not at all impressed with this list.