Re:Programming and Scaling
by gruseom on Saturday August 06, 2011 @08:12PM
(#2855242)
This objection -- "but bad programmers will make a mess of it" -- is the stock objection everybody makes to every unorthodox programming construct. Since it is an objection to everything, it is an objection to nothing.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Programming and Scaling
by michaelochurch on Saturday August 06, 2011 @09:45PM
(#2855437)
This is why I like strong static typing. Instead of bad programmers making a mess of the language, the compiler makes a mess of them.
(I'm half-joking, since there are a variety of bad programmers and not all are of the "can't get code to compile" variety. Actually, the most dangerous bad programmers are the high-IQ bad programmers, but that's another rant. Still, I think it's true that the discipline enforced by languages like ML and Haskell turns a lot of bad programmers away.)
Re:Programming and Scaling
by andrewflnr on Sunday August 07, 2011 @01:43PM
(#2857175)
Just because people overuse it doesn't mean it isn't true sometimes. I don't know if there's a name for that fallacy, but it definitely is one.
That what isn't true? That bad programmers will make a mess? Of course that's true. But if you can't show how and why it's more true of construct X than in general, you've said nothing. Meanwhile, it sounds like you've made a serious objection to X when you haven't.