Text: Chat -> Forums -> Wiki
Video: Twitch -> YouTube -> Movies
Voice: Discord -> Podcasts -> Books on Tape?
Which can be summarized as, in how long the information lasts:
Media: 1 minute -> 1 day -> 1 year
Left side is experimental for people who absolutely love the activity, right side is high quality and condensed for people who just want the information. As the right side has higher standards, it will be more correct but less up to date. On things that are rapidly evolving you might want to drop down to a lower level.
What we need is for it to be as trivial as possible for the information that is happening in chats to make its way to forum posts in a cleaner format, and eventually into wikis where all experimentation has been refined into just truths. All of this needs to be open and so we can't have 9 different services all trying to hold their section hostage.
As information moves from idea to discussion to documentation, choose the right tool for the job. Chat systems like discord, or even an email list, are useful for ephemeral discussion and working things out. Once a concept stabilizes, move it to a wiki that is organized and edited to be a concise, focused document.
One of the key insights when you view the model this way is that people are always trying to avoid "filter bubbles", but it's actually totally okay to have filter bubbles in the idea stage, which should open up in the discussion stage, and should be totally gone by the documentation stage.
So one chat community -> one wiki community doesn't make sense. You want sub-communities that can come together to groom the information as it matures.
Another way to look at this is Breadth First Search vs Depth First Search. DFS moves fast and tries to find new ideas, BFS moves slow and makes sure it's taking the correct path. Think about Chess bots that need to go very far down the search space to make the next move.
It's okay for the idea stage to be bubbly. It helps them come up with ideas. if the wiki stage is of all one mindset, you have an issue.
Further thinking since I made this post, I realized when thinking through this model, no wonder why the internet is so toxic. Most people, the less experienced, who should be reading verified Wiki-level information are reading Facebook and similar, a Chat-level discourse. No wonder disinformation flows.
Of course it makes sense why. Unverified stuff is simply more exciting than known stuff that's been filtered of all of the impossible stuff. How do we get most people to read boring wiki entries? Read textbooks?
Unfortunately, for a gaming organization it really brings to the fore the need for knowledge management, and discipline around what makes its way into the Forum, to a Sticky on the Forum, and from there, to the Wiki as Doctrine/Policy. Kind of comedy how much this needs to resemble RL organizations
However, Slack|Discord individually are vastly inferior individually to:
A Wiki (Take your pick)
Text Based Chat (IRC/XMPP, you choose a client)
Forums (Take your pick)
Voice Chat (Mumble&Murmur/Teamspeak)
Video Streams (Twitch/Youtube/Others)
Mapping Strategy Apps (Take your pick)
Tying this together with a common directory or identity service makes it really integrated, so you don't have 5k identities, but you may have credentials per service. This is what you see many mature gaming organizations doing. Of course, this is serious gaming and less accessible so less idea for a completely open "just join our discord" type community.