News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The worst thing I read this year, and what it taught me (... by Veen on Thursday September 16, 2021 @10:04AM (#28551943)
> Sure, we have to “draw the line”, but isn’t that arbitrary?

Perhaps, insofar as it's arbitrary to be more concerned about the well-being of victims than perpetrators. Personally, I have arbitrarily decided to care more about potential murder victims than convicted murderers, potential rape victims than convicted rapists, property owners than convicted thieves, and so on.

Re:The worst thing I read this year, and what it taught me (... by ashtonkem on Thursday September 16, 2021 @10:31AM (#28552320)
> Perhaps, insofar as it's arbitrary to be more concerned about the well-being of victims than perpetrators.

I’d argue that our current system isn’t really interested in the well being of victims either. Or rather, it’s only interested with the victims when the victims express specific opinions. The actual relationship between crime, survivors, retribution, and forgiveness is an extremely complex matter.

Consider the case of Sirhan Sirhan, and how public figures treated Kennedy family members who were pro-parole vs. anti-parole. Sometimes the same people who were saying “you must listen to the family” were openly attacking other family members for wanting parole!

> Personally, I have arbitrarily decided to care more about potential murder victims than convicted murderers, potential rape victims than convicted rapists, property owners than convicted thieves, and so on.

If that’s what motivates you, you should actively hope for a more merciful and restorative criminal justice system. Our current system has very high recidivism rates, which is very bad for those potential future victims.

Re:The worst thing I read this year, and what it taught me (... by yakshaving_jgt on Thursday September 16, 2021 @11:27AM (#28553031)
When you say “our current system”, which country are you referring to?
Re:The worst thing I read this year, and what it taught me (... by brendoelfrendo on Thursday September 16, 2021 @11:55AM (#28553405)
Contextually, I'm assuming the US, because they specifically mention Sirhan Sirhan, the Kennedy family, and high recidivism rates, all things applicable to the US justice system.
Re:The worst thing I read this year, and what it taught me (... by ashtonkem on Thursday September 16, 2021 @11:57AM (#28553418)
You are correct.
Re:The worst thing I read this year, and what it taught me (... by yakshaving_jgt on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:02PM (#28553484)
That is of course exactly as I suspected since an Americentric view of the world is depressingly common.

I think it’s not useful to form universal views of the world based on the status quo in the USA. The prison system is harsh in the USA, and recidivism is high. In some other countries however, the prisons are significantly more brutal, and yet recidivism is low. So it isn’t quite as simple as the the commenter was implying.

Re:The worst thing I read this year, and what it taught me (... by sombremesa on Thursday September 16, 2021 @10:08AM (#28551992)
Makes sense - I’m well aware no one here cares about anyone else’s wellbeing (but some claims to the contrary sure are good for your image), and you can freely move that line around whenever you want to dunk on someone on Twitter or HN. That’s what life’s about.

Or maybe that’s just Twitter, on HN it’s about saying things everyone agrees with and never bringing up something difficult to respond to, so you won’t get downvoted.

Re:The worst thing I read this year, and what it taught me (... by cybernautique on Thursday September 16, 2021 @11:37AM (#28553166)
Which of these points leads you to declare that the parent doesn't "care about anyone else's well-being?" Genuinely interested.

> Perhaps, insofar as it's arbitrary to be more concerned about the well-being of victims than perpetrators.

[1] Personally, I have arbitrarily decided to care more about potential murder victims than convicted murderers;

[2] potential rape victims than convicted rapists;

[3] property owners than convicted thieves;

[4] and so on.

Re:The worst thing I read this year, and what it taught me (... by gaze on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:17PM (#28553673)
It's strange to put "property owners" in the same list of victims as murder victims and rape victims.