Re:Donate to the Internet Archive
by gego on Thursday September 16, 2021 @03:12AM
(#28548973)
Yes, I know but the reason they did take on the publishers was to fill the void of the closed libraries, who had books (and licences) but could not lend them as they were not open... I looked at the appreciation page of the emergency library during this whole mess, where they asked for use cases of their users and the overwhelming (anecdotal) tone was use for learning, uni, work and less free time - not that that would be a prob. But I understand the curiosity of why they took on publishers and looked into it when publishers first sent out the press release that they would sue... that is what I came up with after looking into it a bit... but interested in other views naturally :)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Donate to the Internet Archive
by matkoniecz on Sunday September 19, 2021 @08:27AM
(#28583782)
Personally I think that several things illegal should be legal, copyright should last about 30 years after death of author and so on.
But Internet Archive quite clearly and blatantly broke law - in situation where their operation were already on edge.
So there is no surprise at all that various entities used this occasion to sue them. Hopefully IA will survive, but I am not impressed by their strategy.