News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Every engineer should do a stint in consulting by jlund-molfese on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @10:58PM (#28547421)
You can also simply apply cold. Ultimately turned the offer down due to concern about burnout, but I had a great experience interviewing with McKinsey. Compared to most tech company interviews, I felt like I was given every opportunity to showcase my strengths as a generalist, and the people I spoke to were all very likeable and invested in the process.
Re:Every engineer should do a stint in consulting by DaiPlusPlus on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:41AM (#28548100)
There's a difference between working as a consultant for a body-shop (no offence - and I do appreciate that McKinsey is nothing like Accenture) compared to doing consulting under your own name though.

Out of curiosity, what would you have been doing under McKinsey?

Re:Every engineer should do a stint in consulting by robertlagrant on Thursday September 16, 2021 @07:42AM (#28550457)
> my strengths as a generalist

I'm curious to understand this phrase, and how the interview process helped.

Re:Every engineer should do a stint in consulting by jlund-molfese on Thursday September 16, 2021 @10:48AM (#28552527)
I think a lot of developers would prefer to sell themselves on their ability to take high-level business problems and work with a team to come up with software solutions, rather than just their raw technical skills. Of course, it's important to understand the details too, but I get more excited by delivering solutions which make my customers' lives easier than implementing a low-level algorithm that already exists in a library somewhere anyway.

McKinsey case studies are more similar to real work than most interviews. You're given a large business problem, and then you're responsible for demonstrating the sorts of questions you'd ask a real client in order to do product discovery and get accurate requirements. Then, you talk about the way you'd architect a solution and go into the details if you have time. At the end of the interview, your interviewer asks you realistic questions like a client would.

I do like pair programming exercises (the ones where you get a realistic problem with an open-ended solution, not the type where the interviewer yells at you until you get the One and Only Solution). And McK does a bit of that too, with questions which validate your ability to develop across the stack, but aren't anything you wouldn't encounter in a normal day at work ("implement a JS component in whatever framework you want", "given this table structure, write a query to do X in whatever SQL dialect you want", "implement a basic REST API to fulfill this use case in whatever language you want").

Re:Every engineer should do a stint in consulting by robertlagrant on Saturday September 18, 2021 @11:56AM (#28577175)
Thanks - understood!
Re:Every engineer should do a stint in consulting by aerioux on Wednesday September 15, 2021 @11:53PM (#28547788)
different teams are very different but I also can say McK Analytics was +10 -- lots of invested and interesting people.

Though I do see that only 1/6 of my interview panel is still there 4 years later?