Nimbys are simply protecting an investment. In a captalistic society we have to change the incentives to drive action.
Allow renters vote on local zoning regulation. Hell, remove stringent zoning regulations in general. At the same time, put limitations on what HOAs and local.commitees are allowed to impose.
Remove the exorbidant costs/regulations towards building multi family homes. This has been driving the rise 'premium condos' because affordable housing isnt affordable to build.
Impose larger taxes on rent collected on 3rd+ homes. Impose large taxes on vacant properties. Start gently discouraging additional housing as an investment.
Lastly, I strongly support sensible gentrification. Give long term renters first dibs and zero-additional-cost pathways to home ownership.But after that, gentrify and gentrify heavily. A revitalization of innercities is the easiest way to solve the housing problem in our current political climate. (For those who complain that condos arent suburban single family homes.....thats how we got here in the first place)
These are just some ideas .
What does this mean? If any zoning regulation comes up for public vote, everyone elegible to vote gets to vote on it.
Or are you suggesting renters should have special access to vote on these issues?
There's little to no regulations on flippers. They can be DIY people that have never swung a hammer or people that cut every corner possible to squeeze out every cent of profit. Often, buyers of flipped properties are doing major repairs in the first 2 years as things behind the walls was not done correctly. It's a very common tale of people completely renovating their newly renovated bathrooms and kitchens (yes, the most expensive rooms in your house) because the flippers did not take the time to properly waterproof behind the tiles. Or they did not properly mortar the tiles for adhesion and they are now popping up.
That's not quite how it works though. How much the investor spent in changes is not relevant. What matters is how much the next buyer values those changes.
If the investor bought the place for 300K and spent 50K on giant pink flamingo statues all over the yard, the next buyer will likely offer less than 300K.
Only if they spent 50K on improvements that the next buyer feels are worth it an increase the value, then they'll offer more. But in that case, value actually was added.
The next buyer usually feels like the home is over priced. Because it is. They know it is, but they lack optionality because a majority of the active MLS listings are flipped homes. Think of it as they are forcing the next buyer to pay as much as they can possibly afford. Sure, low interest helps the "afford more" but it doesn't mean they are comfortable or happy spending that amount. It doesn't mean they necessarily value it either. They may have been happy with the original condition at $300K but they never saw that option. It was an off market transaction.
> Only if they spent 50K on improvements that the next buyer feels are worth it an increase the value, then they'll offer more. But in that case, value actually was added.
Sure they feel $50K was added. But not another $100K of profit for the flipper who only held the property for 8 weeks before re-listing it. The $100K, 20% of the new "value", is completely intangible and not real. This is supposed to be real estate after all.
Flipping doesn't really exist when appreciation is low. Remember how no one was flipping houses in 2010? And then in 2012, suddenly everyone in their mom started flipping houses again?
It only makes sense when asset appreciation is high. You'll find that most of the "value added" is simply them holding the house for 6 months and capturing appreciation (on leverage).
In my opinion, the "value added" is more correlated with what new construction on the similar land would cost. As lumber prices went up last year, existing homes went up too because the cost of building became higher. Essentially, a flipper wants you to feel like you have a new home at a discount and you'll pay the optimal amount for it.
If they are willing to pay more for better housing, what's the problem?
Of course, they're not willing to "pay more". Interest rates get lowered, and they can keep the same payment and buy more house.
The reason flipping is attractive is because Central Banks push up house prices - which flippers capture on leverage. If it weren't for house prices artificially appreciating so much (by constantly lower interest rates) - there wouldn't be any profits to be made flipping houses. Transaction costs are too high.
The time that flippers spend "improving" a house is time that the house isn't on the market at all for a potential resident.
Don't think of flippers as individual actors on small scales repairing and reselling a house here or there, think of companies that literally buy whole neighborhoods (hundreds of houses) and rent some of them out while they tear down or "improve" the rest. They can afford to keep the rental price high and/or let it sit vacant because the real money will be in the eventual sale.
You're right that they "gain" partly from inflation, but that's only one piece of the puzzle. It's a combination of large operations (and a large number of smaller operations) that essentially act as a cartel that effectively limits the supply of available homes for purchase.
However, the quality of work topic is a major issue and extremely common. It raises the cost of ownership going forward.
People want to buy "nice" houses. But too many houses for sale need a lot of work done for them still. Enter flippers to make the market.
The average person does not want to buy a house and renovate it for a year while living in it so that they can save $30k. Most people don't have the skills, time, risk appetite, or desire. Let alone all 4. With 2.75% 30-year fixed rates, it's only a savings of $120/m.
If capital is so cheap, why is there no convenient vehicle that allows the buyer to buy an ugly home and hire a contractor to fix it up before moving in? (Construction loans are a joke). The $300K house with $50K fixes now cost $350K which is the value that was added. The flipper added $100K of fake value. I don't see that as real value just because some sucker came and paid it. People overpay for houses even in hot markets, all, the, time. People are motivated by all kinds of things. They have time constraints, moving for a job, kids starting school, etc, etc and sometimes they just pay what they have to to get what they want. It doesn't mean it's right and having so much of people's income going towards a mortgage isn't good for anyone except the flipper. So while I understand they play a part of today's real estate industry construct, I feel like we'd collectively be better off without them.
When flipping reaches a high level of market penetration (eg. a majority of listings are flipped homes) it gets more perverse. The pricing is completely made up, borderline or outright collusion is taking place, and the prices do not reflect value. Housing is a need, so somebody is paying the price and thus meeting your definition of "value add" but it's not real.
> How is this different from the middle man at the grocery store who makes pre-made salads and sandwiches and soups, so that you don't have to?
It's not. But his prices likely reflect something reasonable. And if not, I have infinite optionality. Without optionality, it turns into the ballpark where a hotdog cost $15
How is this different than Mercedes and BMW vs Honda and Toyota?
It's not like people are only allowed to pay more for things that you think are actually worth more.
People regularly spend lots of money on what many people consider waste. Why shouldn't they be allowed to do it on housing? New construction is just as rife with this problem, I think.
Houses are built with a ridiculous set of boxes that need to be checked by buyers. They are not built to be actual livable houses. They're built to be sold.
The flipper is just making money via arbitrage. The 'profit' they make is simply: (holding cost + holding risk) * time + value of improvements + cost of hassle of renovating
Here's one of the papers: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S10511...
It shows that AirBNBs do push up rents - but even in desirable parts of Boston with a lot of AirBNBs - it's /only/ responsible for a 0.4% increase.
Keep in mind that rents have been increasing by >4% per year for 20 years in Boston. A .4% increase is 10% of that. General inflation is /at least/ 50% of it. The other ~40% is coming from elsewhere.
Unless AirBNBs make up a substantial portion of new sales - it is hard to blame them for the majority of price increases.
Oh they are real - it's just that 90% of them reside in Zürich, Switzerland.
From my understanding, it appears there is NOT a government agency backing them, though. I don't think the 3.5% downpayment market be very big in the US if not for Fannie and Freddie (it basically doesn't exist outside of conventional loans Fannie & Freddie will buy).
I don't know how big the market is in the UK - maybe it's not much of an issue?
I'd love to hear from someone who knows more about this part of the UK market.
>Between July 2019 and June 2020, the average down payment for a home amounted to 12% of the home value. In the first three months of 2021, 48% of home buyers made a down payment of at least 20% of the home value. 21% of home buyers in that same period made an all-cash purchase. [1]
It sounds like 69% are >= 20% down or all cash. I don't think enabling lower income access to housing is hurting our housing market at all.
1. https://www.fool.com/the-ascent/research/average-down-paymen...
Housing is very much at the margin and a small increase/decrease of demand will have an outsized effect on price. However, I'm not going to argue that everybody poorer than me shouldn't have access to a house just so I can get one at a cheaper price ...
[1]: https://inhabit.corcoran.com/new-york-city-residential-renta...
What's wrong with renting? Why are poor people entitled to home ownership when most of the young middle class isn't? Why can't they rent?
There would be no problem with rent if home-ownership wasn't a massive handout from the government by guaranteeing that home prices appreciate more than interest rates. This is extremely unfair to poor people as it is currently - because they can't get in line to get massive amounts of free money. Best they can get is SNAP.
Meanwhile, your local millionaire is getting >$20k per year in asset subsidization.
I don't think that even more manipulation is the solution to the problem. If the government could get out of the business of pumping up house prices while keeping benefits like SNAP, that would go a long way toward fixing inequality.
These are just excuses. These aren't real problems.
The real problem is artificially low interest rates, artificial scarcity caused by NIMBYism, low downpayments (backed by Fannie & Freddie), tax breaks for home owners but not for renters, high income taxes, low property taxes, etc...
The vast majority of homeowners are just everyday regular homeowners, almost twice as many as everyday regular landlords. Little old ladies and short term rental operators make up <3% of the market. You can only blame them for much.