Re:Google blames a Human for its Robot Car Accident
by joebadmo on Friday August 05, 2011 @05:49PM
(#2851932)
Anyone else disturbed by the weirdly Luddite/anti-Google tone of this piece? Is there some reason not to take Google's statement about the human driver at face value? Is there really anything more to this story than: "A human quite unremarkably crashed a car into another car, as happens millions of times a year"?
Re:Google blames a Human for its Robot Car Accident
by sliverstorm on Friday August 05, 2011 @08:05PM
(#2852334)
To be fair, as best I understand it an airplane cruising at altitude is not very hard to pilot. Nothing to run into, nobody merging into your airstream- nothing much more complicated than "steady as she goes"
I believe takeoff, ascent, landing and descent is still done by pilots.
Additionally, trouble with cars is, they have evolved for 100 years around sight as the primary navigation function. Planes almost never had that luxury, so they have relied on instruments for a long time. Computers are good at instruments, not so good at sight.
Re:Google blames a Human for its Robot Car Accident
by awaz on Friday August 05, 2011 @06:34PM
(#2852074)
I am not disturbed. Why would a human driver be driving an automated car? What is the security mechanisms that allow such cars to be in the streets? Isn't there a need for independent monitoring for such experiments?
Re:Google blames a Human for its Robot Car Accident
by ajju on Friday August 05, 2011 @06:38PM
(#2852089)
All Google self driving cars have a human driver who can take control at any time. I don't know if the human was driving the car when this accident occurred, but so far there is no evidence supporting the notion that Google is lying to the cops (which would be a crime).
Re:Google blames a Human for its Robot Car Accident
by ENOTTY on Friday August 05, 2011 @06:42PM
(#2852106)
> Why would a human driver be driving an automated car?
Because Google cannot legally operate the car in the streets without a driver. Therefore they put a driver there and it's on him to choose how to drive the car.
> What is the security mechanisms that allow such cars to be in the streets?
The wonderful security mechanism of liability, lawsuits, and insurance.
Re:Google blames a Human for its Robot Car Accident
by bdonlan on Friday August 05, 2011 @06:39PM
(#2852097)
The security mechanism _is_ the human driver, for now - the only reason they're legally allowed to run these cars is because there's a human standing by to take over control at a moment's notice.
Re:Google blames a Human for its Robot Car Accident
by drivebyacct2 on Friday August 05, 2011 @06:46PM
(#2852116)
I didn't necessarily assume an anti-Google tone, but I did mutter "what the hell?" when I read "Glad no one appears hurt, but this is a good reminder of one of the main reasons Google’s experiment with robot cars both fascinates us and creeps us out.".
If it was human error, 160K miles have been logged without incident... how the hell is this a good reminder of why we should be creeped out by Google's experiment? (edit: The last sentence of that last paragraph is equally useless.) I'm no journalist but I feel comfortable rolling my eyes at this article and its style.
Re:Google blames a Human for its Robot Car Accident
by pavel_lishin on Friday August 05, 2011 @06:36PM
(#2852081)
I love the random guesses in the comments, despite any actual facts in the article. I literally don't know what caused the crash - did the human drive have total control and bump someone?
Re:Google blames a Human for its Robot Car Accident
by sliverstorm on Friday August 05, 2011 @06:45PM
(#2852113)
It's like they are trying to say "look at what bad things can happen when humans crash cars. Aren't you afraid of robots also crashing cars? Even though Google's robots have never crashed cars, and thus already a better track record than nearly every human?"
I believe takeoff, ascent, landing and descent is still done by pilots.
Additionally, trouble with cars is, they have evolved for 100 years around sight as the primary navigation function. Planes almost never had that luxury, so they have relied on instruments for a long time. Computers are good at instruments, not so good at sight.
Because Google cannot legally operate the car in the streets without a driver. Therefore they put a driver there and it's on him to choose how to drive the car.
> What is the security mechanisms that allow such cars to be in the streets?
The wonderful security mechanism of liability, lawsuits, and insurance.
If it was human error, 160K miles have been logged without incident... how the hell is this a good reminder of why we should be creeped out by Google's experiment? (edit: The last sentence of that last paragraph is equally useless.) I'm no journalist but I feel comfortable rolling my eyes at this article and its style.