News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel issues end-of-life notice for RealSense Lidar by worrycue on Monday September 13, 2021 @01:34PM (#28514252)
This isn’t the first time Intel has flirted with things outside their core competence. They dabbled with SSDs, mobile phone modems, … etc. It’s just something Intel does. Why? Don’t know.
Re:Intel issues end-of-life notice for RealSense Lidar by bluGill on Monday September 13, 2021 @01:49PM (#28514430)
All companies need to flirt with things that might be good. Some of those things will turn out so great that you leave your orignial company behind, while others will be duds that you drop, and still others will be small side businesses that make you a bit of money in down times but otherwise are just barely worth doing. Intel used to be a memory company that flirted with making CPUs. I don't recall when they left the memory business (I think in the 1980s)
Re:Intel issues end-of-life notice for RealSense Lidar by kevin_thibedeau on Monday September 13, 2021 @02:07PM (#28514690)
Intel used to be a RAM company that sold microprocessors as a side business.
Re:Intel issues end-of-life notice for RealSense Lidar by morcheeba on Monday September 13, 2021 @02:10PM (#28514731)
The sad thing is that Intel had a real advantage in RealSense... they had good processors in there (especially with the Movidius chips) that were well integrated (e.g. they didn't have to support a fancy SDK for all users - just the internal Realsense group). Doing the same 3d processing with ARM or Intel is 1/10th the frame rate at much more power.
Re:Intel issues end-of-life notice for RealSense Lidar by snovv_crash on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:03PM (#28617968)
Thing is, my personal perspective (haha) is that single-shot stereo is a dead-end tech. There simply isn't enough information to infer depth in the difficult situations, range is severely limited, and every frame it basically re-calculates all of the information from the previous frame from scratch, making it wildly inefficient.

Of course, it works well as a tech demo and in controlled environments, and it's easy to understand and then brute-force with custom hardware. The problem is that it sucked the life out of better techniques which might actually work in the real world.

Re:Intel issues end-of-life notice for RealSense Lidar by reasonabl_human on Monday September 13, 2021 @02:24PM (#28514896)
Can you elaborate on the benefits of what intel built here as opposed to doing the processing on host machines? My company uses these in some products but I never investigated the market or trade space for this type of device
Re:Intel issues end-of-life notice for RealSense Lidar by morcheeba on Monday September 13, 2021 @02:45PM (#28515137)
Yeah! There is a lot of processing to do the disparity calculation... it's basically doing lots of correlations with a different amount of x shift and finding the delta-x that has the highest correlation. This delta-x disparity gets calculated in to a z distance.

So, intel made a custom processor for this that's really good at the correlations. The original one was the D4, and later they used their movidius chip. Both have lots of multiplier-accumulate silicon, so it can do the computations in parallel. Their architectures are also set up for convolution (which re-uses a lot of data) rather than random-processing (like a CPU does), so they could feed these math engines without a lot of data transfer -- this makes it more power efficient. You could do something similar in an FPGA, but dedicated silicon is going to be faster, cheaper, and use less power.

Re:Intel issues end-of-life notice for RealSense Lidar by ashtonkem on Monday September 13, 2021 @07:10PM (#28518101)
Funny how we now forget that at one point in time Intel was dabbling in CPUs when their core competence was DRAM chips. Things change.
Re:Intel issues end-of-life notice for RealSense Lidar by sseagull on Monday September 13, 2021 @02:11PM (#28514736)
Tech companies don't know what to do with all their money (although Intel perhaps a bit less so).

Google's core is search & advertising. But they are also in email, video streaming, messaging & video chat, cloud computing, mobile phones, gaming (Stadia), self-driving cars, drone delivery, quantum computing, and probably many other things that I can't think of.

Edit: Yes I know it’s technically Alphabet, but in practical terms, it’s Google

Re:Intel issues end-of-life notice for RealSense Lidar by rualca on Monday September 13, 2021 @02:37PM (#28515033)
> Tech companies don't know what to do with all their money (although Intel perhaps a bit less so).

Lidar has high computational needs, which directly influences accuracy, and both spacial and time resolution.

Post-processing steps also have high computational needs, such as infering structure, do coregistration, handle point density, etc.

Also, practical applications often demand and depend on meeting constraints such as low power requirements and size.

If a company such as Intel managed to leverage their know-how to provide Lidar hardware that was competitive in both performance and price then they could as well develop a machine that prints money.

Re:Intel issues end-of-life notice for RealSense Lidar by thrashh on Monday September 13, 2021 @01:49PM (#28514433)
I mean we’ve had Bell Labs et. al. and now we have transistors, Unix, CCDs to allow digital cameras, etc…

They can keep on trucking with R&D

Re:Intel issues end-of-life notice for RealSense Lidar by yann2 on Monday September 13, 2021 @01:51PM (#28514452)
They are big enough to take the loss. No harm in trying.
Re:Intel issues end-of-life notice for RealSense Lidar by joezydeco on Monday September 13, 2021 @03:07PM (#28515422)
Unless you actually get duped into using XScale, Zephyr, Edison, etc....
Re:Intel issues end-of-life notice for RealSense Lidar by snovv_crash on Monday September 13, 2021 @02:09PM (#28514713)
I get SSDs and modems, this allows them to leverage their fabs. Maybe even CCDs. But 3D computational geometry, camera lenses and LIDAR? And drones? This seems a bit out-of-line to me.