News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by chrisseaton on Monday September 13, 2021 @11:39AM (#28512858)
> India and China could easily become the majority of immigrants due to the population size.

Ok?

What’s your problem with that?

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by Veen on Monday September 13, 2021 @11:49AM (#28513003)
It's not very diverse, is it? You'd end up with many times more people from India and China as from the whole of Africa, for example. Basically no one from small nations would get a green card.

The problem is that the number of green cards is relatively fixed, so there has to be some way to distribute them that prevents two nations from taking almost all the spots.

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by triceratops on Monday September 13, 2021 @12:24PM (#28513418)
> It's not very diverse, is it?

Why do you think India and China aren't diverse by themselves, and within themselves? India probably has more languages than all of Europe. Would it be sensible to treat Europe (or even just the Schengen area) as one country, to "increase diversity"? I think that would be dumb. European countries are obviously very diverse and we see that more clearly because they're sovereign nations on a map. India and China are mega-countries and we fail to appreciate the diversity within.

> Basically no one from small nations would get a green card

Why would that happen? It would be a first-come-first-served system. If a person from a small nation applies, they'll get it at the same time as someone from a bigger nation who applied at the same time as them (modulo processing time variances).

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by cyberlurker on Monday September 13, 2021 @12:46PM (#28513672)
This is a really good point I had not considered before. I assume there is no policy to look for diversity within countries? That’s a shame, because probably many majority nationals from one country may apply and many minorities from those countries are unlikely to make it through.
Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by triceratops on Monday September 13, 2021 @01:33PM (#28514239)
There isn't any "look for diversity" policy at all. The law simply establishes caps for the number of green cards issued to applicants based on country of birth. Country of birth is considered a proxy for diversity. If countries were generally of a similar size IRL, and had similar rates of migration to the US, it might work better.
Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by Veen on Monday September 13, 2021 @12:27PM (#28513450)
> Would it be sensible to treat Europe as one country

Why would it? Europe isn't a country. India and China are countries. I fail to see your point. It's obviously more diverse if Chinese, Indians, Europeans, South Americans, Africans etc have a more or less equal chance, and that's what the current rules are supposed to provide.

> It would be a first-come-first-served system

So you think immigration status should be determined by whether someone gets their forms in on the 1st of January or not? I'm not sure that's entirely practical or fair. Perhaps a lottery would be more suitable.

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by triceratops on Monday September 13, 2021 @12:34PM (#28513535)
> Europe isn't a country. India and China are countries. I fail to see your point

The point was in the rest of my comment. "Country" doesn't imply a homogenous, non-diverse group of people. And "diversity" is the purported reason for country-of-birth caps.

> It's obviously more diverse if Chinese, Indians, Europeans, South Americans, Africans

You said China and India are countries, then went on to compare them to continents. Surely you see the fallacy here.

> someone gets their forms in on the 1st of January or not?

I didn't say anything about the 1st of January (or any other date). "First-come-first-served" means applications are treated on their merits and processed in the order they arrived. If two people with the same application, but different country of birth, apply at the same time, they should have roughly same result in the same amount of time. That's not the case today. And I'm struggling to understand how a single queue is "unfair".

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by monocasa on Monday September 13, 2021 @01:04PM (#28513877)
For immigration purposes, since the EU is one open territory, it absolutely could make sense to treat it as a single entity if you buy into the base ideas here behind the caps.
Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by Veen on Monday September 13, 2021 @01:12PM (#28513979)
Maybe, but I didn’t mention the EU. I said Europe.
Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by monocasa on Monday September 13, 2021 @02:57PM (#28515296)
The common legal system that includes immigration which covers the vast majority of Europeans seems on topic for your point, AFAICT. Can you elaborate more how you think it's not applicable?
Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by arcticbull on Monday September 13, 2021 @11:54AM (#28513064)
> It's not very diverse, is it?

The responsibility of an immigration program to its citizens isn't necessarily to maximize diversity. It's to maximize the benefit to the country. A points-based immigration program would allow the country to optimize along any number of axes: under-represented minorities, skills, etc.

> The problem is that the number of green cards is relatively fixed, so there has to be some way to distribute them that prevents two nations from taking almost all the spots.

Is it? Canada brings in 3x as many immigrants per capita as the US does. It's brought in 1% of its population each year for roughly the last 100 years - so the equivalent of 3-4M green cards per year. I think there's probably a lot of wiggle room.

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by 908B64B197 on Monday September 13, 2021 @02:58PM (#28515309)
> A points-based immigration program would allow the country to optimize along any number of axes: under-represented minorities, skills, etc.

That's what the cap is for.

> Canada brings in 3x as many immigrants per capita as the US does. It's brought in 1% of its population each year for roughly the last 100 years - so the equivalent of 3-4M green cards per year.

Almost every week there's a thread with Canadian Engineers whining about low pay. How are these out of control immigration quotas helping them out?

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by arcticbull on Monday September 13, 2021 @03:06PM (#28515407)
> That's what the cap is for.

Yes, but it selects for the wrong things. It's an axe when you need a scalpel.

> Almost every week there's a thread with Canadian Engineers whining about low pay. How are these out of control immigration quotas helping them out?

What on earth do you mean "out of control" lol. That's a value judgement you made that you're projecting.

Canada has low inequality. Most people are paid roughly the same amount - in line with much of Western Europe. The US is closer to PNG, the Philippines, Turkey and Madagascar. You can't have low inequality and high pay for one group. [1] Canadians value that. You don't, and that's ok too.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_income_eq...

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by 908B64B197 on Monday September 13, 2021 @03:46PM (#28515872)
> You can't have low inequality and high pay for one group.

You also can't have overachievers. This becomes obvious when looking at academia. [0]

These individuals are the ones bootstrapping entire businesses and economic sectors.

[0] https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-global-brain-trade

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by arcticbull on Monday September 13, 2021 @04:06PM (#28516133)
Of course you can have overachievers, I suspect this is a very American perspective. Japan Airlines' CEO makes $90K a year. Money isn't the be all and end all, promotions come with more pay and more social status.

[edit] did you not have overachievers in high school and college? I suspect they weren't getting paid! Quite the opposite.

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by refurb on Monday September 13, 2021 @09:47PM (#28519229)
As a Canadian that’s hilarious. “Were going to pay you much less than other countries do and we’re actually doing you a favor”.
Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by arcticbull on Monday September 13, 2021 @10:28PM (#28519490)
Nobody said anything about doing anyone any favors.

I said that the wealth inequality was lower, and inequality being lower by definition requires that pay bands are compressed.

Keep in mind that when you compare against international salaries, you have to convert not just to a neutral currency, but also adjust for PPP. Canada's PPP adjustment factor is close to +15%. That is to say, 1 USD goes 15% further in Canada than it does in America.

There are pros and cons to a more egalitarian society. Certain groups that would do better in other countries do worse, and in exchange certain groups that would do worse in other countries do better.

Per Levels.fyi a:

- Shopify L7 makes $324K USD ($372K PPP).

- That's a Google L5 at $356K.

- A Facebook E5 at $390K.

- Or a Microsoft level 65 at $287K.

Remote changes the game a bit here, but in the past your Shopify L7 would have gone infinitely further in Ottawa than your Facebook E5 would have gone down in MPK. Local PPP matters too.

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by refurb on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @12:20AM (#28520177)
You accounting for taxes? HST? Gasoline taxes? The general higher cost of anything imported? How about the recent run up in housing costs? Houses are about as expensive in Toronto as they are the Bay area now.

Having worked in both countries, $300k USD goes way further in the US than $300k CAD in Canada. And that's even accounting for the housing difference.

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by arcticbull on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @12:47PM (#28527427)
> You accounting for taxes?

Yes, taxes are very comparable in California and New York on this income level. 400,000 CAD in Ontario is taxed at a net effective 44.8%. In BC 43.8%

In California you'd be taxed at an effective 42%. In New York you'd be taxed at an effective 43.2%. And after the Biden tax hikes go into effect this starts to look a lot worse.

Not to mention the Canadian tax bill includes healthcare whereas the US salary is reduced by $12,000 a year to account for it.

> HST? Gasoline? The general higher cost of anything imported?

You're making $400K a year and you think that a $55 average monthly gas bill is going to make a difference?

Yes this is all factored into the PPP adjustment. [1]

> How about the recent run up in housing costs?

It happened in both countries.

> Having worked in both countries, $300k USD goes way further in the US than $300k CAD in Canada.

I suspect this isn't true.

Now you can cherry-pick non-tech cities in the US, but I can do that with Canada too, and of course, the vast majority of tech folks have historically chosen to live in NY and CA for a reason. Will that hold? Who knows!

[1] https://www.oecd.org/sdd/prices-ppp/purchasingpowerparities-...

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by 908B64B197 on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @01:18PM (#28527844)
There's also currency (one USD will always be worth one USD!) and capital gain tax (on your RSU).
Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by arcticbull on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @02:08PM (#28528473)
1CAD will also always be 1CAD. People who live in Canada are paid in CAD, people who live in America are paid in USD. The currency and PPP conversions smoothed out those differences for comparison purposes. I selected a mid-band senior Shopify role in Toronto denominated in CAD as the comparison and ran the appropriate adjustments.

In the US, RSU vesting is considered ordinary income and taxed accordingly, this was considered and included.

[edit] I believe in Canada, RSU vesting is also ordinary income, but if not then treating them as a capital gain will substantially reduce the tax burden for Canadians.

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by 908B64B197 on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @03:57PM (#28530208)
> 1CAD will also always be 1CAD. People who live in Canada are paid in CAD, people who live in America are paid in USD.

One of them is a stable reserve currency. Goods are priced in USD then the exchange rate is used to get the final price in other currencies.

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by arcticbull on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @04:44PM (#28530839)
Actually, one other important note: 1USD isn't really always 1USD in the sense that imports become relatively more or less expensive for Americans in America. Reserve status doesn't really correlate too much.

Check out DXY. You'll see that as compared to a basket of other world currencies the USD has ranged substantially, from 0.76 in 2012 to as high as 1.02 in 2016. [1]

Being the reserve currency more often than not means that its a unit of account.

[1] https://www.investing.com/currencies/us-dollar-index

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by arcticbull on Tuesday September 14, 2021 @04:30PM (#28530649)
Exchange rates really don't matter much for most people.

Most people buy goods at home.

Relative strength and weakness of a particular currency against another just indicates whether imports are more economical or whether manufacturing at home + exporting are more economical.

This change over time is reflected in both exchange rates and accounted for in PPP adjustment. It may fluctuate over time, but I don't think that's a huge deal when deciding which country you plan to work in.

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by 908B64B197 on Monday September 13, 2021 @10:48PM (#28519621)
Isn't the biggest budget item housing?
Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by rmk on Monday September 13, 2021 @08:38PM (#28518762)
There is a diversity visa category that is specifically geared toward getting diverse immigrants from all over the world. Increasing diversity is not a goal of the employment-based green card system, and neither is it a goal in the family-based green card system (it is family unification).

The reason for caps is historical. The idea was to reduce any ethnic group from wielding too strong an influence on politics by immigrating in large numbers, but that is now moot because of mostly uncontrolled/lenient immigration from Latin America over decades.

The main problem with the US immigration system is the high prevalence of family immigration vs. employment-based immigration. The majority of professional immigrants, such as the doctors who serve rural areas, medical/pharma researchers, postgrads in various scientific disciplines and software and high-tech industry employees are drawn from the latter category, and the majority face insanely long wait periods. This is rapidly eroding the attractiveness of the US as a destination for these people, which can only harm the future prospects of the country.

Re:France grants citizenship to 12,000 Covid frontline workers by chrisseaton on Monday September 13, 2021 @11:52AM (#28513038)
> there has to be some way to distribute them that prevents two nations from taking almost all the spots

But why?

Why is it so important to you what countries people are coming from?