Re:Parachute use to prevent death and major trauma: systemat...
by ricardobeat on Monday September 13, 2021 @03:15AM
(#28508670)
You can put the mask “controversy” under this perspective: do we know how surgical masks and airborne diseases work? Do we need more data to prove their effectiveness?
Re:Parachute use to prevent death and major trauma: systemat...
by spockz on Monday September 13, 2021 @02:32AM
(#28508414)
Re [0]: Apparently Leonardo da Vinci has the earliest design but the first actual implementation goes to Sébastien Lenormand. https://www.da-vinci-inventions.com/parachute
If we had no observational evidence for something, but we instead had an underlying model that made many correct predictions, then it would be fair to draw their conclusion that clinical trials aren't the end-all-be-all. But when you're operating solely on raw data with little to no understanding, you need data.[2]
Of course, I am most decidedly an amateur in all the fields I've mentioned, so take all this with a grain of salt :-)
[0] I don't actually know how parachutes were discovered, so maybe they were discovered purely experimentally. I'm inclined to doubt it, given a presumed lack of willing test subjects—but if I'm wrong, hopefully my comment will have value nonetheless.
[1] To be fair, my understanding is that this applies to mainstream medicine too (isn't "how do general anesthetics work" still an open question?).
[2] I feel this is a massive problem with current AI/ML trends as well. My undergrad "intro to ML" class briefly covered the statistics of it (VC dimensions and all that). The prof. basically said, "here's the amount of data you need to get statistical guarantees of correctness... and in practice, you'll have orders of magnitude less data than this." And yet we put this half-baked tech into cars, because it works on the happy cases, and totally ignore the lack of statistical confidence regarding the bad cases.